Sir Richard F. Burton on the Web: Message Board

Return to Topics
|
Post a reply/new message
|
Return to Web Page

Post a reply/new message

Topic: Burton, Castle and Hutton

Started by Peter H on 1/8/02, 7:44 AM


Subject

Burton, Castle and Hutton

Name

Peter H ([email protected])

Writen

1/8/02, 7:44 AM

I'm interested in doing some research into the books of swordsmanship and fencing proficiency of Burton, Egerton Castle and Alfred Hutton, can anyone offer any recommendations.

Many thanks
Peter


Subject

swordplay by Burton, Castle

Name

roark mitzell ([email protected])

Writen

1/10/02, 1:02 PM

Hello Peter,
You are probably already aware of the following books, but just in case you aren't...
Burton's two main books on swords/swordsmanship%3B The Book of the Sword


Subject

Swordplay

Name

Richard Leveson ([email protected])

Writen

1/11/02, 8:43 AM

Link

http://burton.richardleveson.com

Hello Peter

I am no expert in sword-lore but Burton won the accolade "Maitre d'Armes (Brevete)" and his two books, as Roak above was saying, were "The Book of the Sword", Chatto


Subject

Burton on swords

Name

Michael Macciola ([email protected])

Writen

2/15/02, 10:47 AM

Hi
Being a fencer and an admirer of Burton's writings I have found some interesting overlap here. I know of four writings by Burton regarding swordsmanship. They are(in no order) The Book of the Sword, Sentiment of the Sword, A Complete System of Bayonet Exercises and A New System of Sword Exercises. I would welcome any information regarding Burton's history with the sword with regards to his training. I see the above title of "Maitre de Armes(Brevet), does this mean that Burton was not an approved Maitre but rather given an honorary, or unofficial title? This is what I guess seeing the Brevet part....just curious.



Subject

Ruffian Dick and swordsmanship

Name

Roark Mitzell ([email protected])

Writen

4/18/02, 3:23 PM

Hello Michael,
On the subject of Burton's training as a swordsman%3B I don't think anyone has ever sat down and tried to list the masters Burton studied with. If memory serves, a number of his fencing masters are listed in the wave of biographies which have come out in the past fifteen years or so, beginning with Byron Farwell's. For certain, Burton studied in France as a child, in Vienna, and I think there is mention made of a Hungarian. Burton's celebrated bout in Bologne is mentioned in nearly every biography where he faced a noted swordsman, but contemptuously decline the use of a mask, disarmed the Frenchman a number of times, and received a single touch in the throat. If you have access to burton's "The Sentiment of the Sword", I feel this thinly disguised salute to Baron Brazoncourt's earlier "Secrets of the Sword", tells us more about Burton's training and preferences than any other writing. His protagonist repeatedly speaks of the virtues of the Neoplitain style fencing- which obviously is neither French, Italian or Spanish. As a fencing teacher, I have been experimenting with Burton's recommended traingle of guards for foil' tierce, seconde, and carte. Tierce, these days , is only used with sabre, but I have found it to be an amazingly strong, if slow guard in foil, and due to its slowness, one must keep a greater distance between you and your opponent in that guard. Counter-parries work well, but a teirce parry is weak, and swinging to a parry in carte is also takes a great deal of time to become accustomed to... The foil, in tierce, is almost held in a "battle axe" grip, so point control lessens as strength increases. As soon, however, as I began bouting in tierce, the revelation came as to how Burton had repeatedly disarmed his French foe with a "downward beat". The third (tierce) position grants the blade emmense power- especially for a downward beat which- to the best of my knowledge- is not and never has been taught in the French School. I heartily recommend a careful reading of "The Sentiment of the Sword". And, if I ever find time to make a list- from all those myriad broigraphies- of Burton's masters, I shall post it on this
site. Finally, due to the accolades Burton received for his ability with the sword, I have always beleived that his title was not a mere honorarium. Isabelle, at one point, mentions an attack developed by Burton and although the specifics of her comment escapes me, she left no doubt that his title of maitre d'armes had been earned, and that he was respected across Europe as a premiere fencer.





Subject

Ruffian Dick and Swordsmanship.

Name

Michael Macciola

Writen

5/16/02, 3:55 PM

Roark,
Thanks for the thorough post. Your points are all well taken. I should re-read some of those bio.'s of Burton and try to note his masters. I agree Sentiment of the Sword is Burton's homage to the Baron's "Secrets" and does state his fencing preferences better than any listing of his teachers could.


Subject

Ruffian Dick and Swordsmanship

Name

roark mitzell ([email protected])

Writen

5/17/02, 9:44 AM

Michael, Just curious. Do you have a copy of Burton's "New Sword Exercises"? A photo-copy of this manual has just come into my hands quite accidentally. It is an intersting read, and a kind of companion volume for the "Sentiment of the Sword". "Sentiment", I feel gives us a better look at Burton's foil style. "New Sword" deals primarily with cuts (military as opposed to civilian duel or foil scenario), and Burton devised a system of 10 figure-eight cuts beginning at the head and ending with a final 11th and 12th to the flanks. An interesting peice, and a must for any admirer of Burton as a swordsman. If you don't have a copy of this book, I would happily copy and send your way. Again, I think "Sentiment" is more valuable for a modern classical, as opposed to sport, fencer.


Subject

Burton and his fencing.

Name

Marcus ([email protected])

Writen

5/21/02, 10:50 PM

One thing to keep in mind about the bout in Bologne is that they were using regular sabers that may or may not have been blunted. The clue to that is that he hurt the French mans arm. In regular fencing with foils, epee and saber using the fingers to control, the saber would have flew out of his hand with little or no pain. But in using at least regulation weight weapons even if blunted, they would have to grip the sword tightly as in real life instead of fencing. This would have in turn caused the pain and injury.


Subject

Burton and his fencing

Name

roark mitzell ([email protected])

Writen

5/23/02, 11:59 AM

I'll need to check the exact quotes from the various biographies which mention this bout, but as I recall, there is specific mention of the contest being with foils. Burton, as I recollect, escapes with but a single "prod" to the neck. Although thrusts are absolutely valid in sabre bouting, the "weapons" in this case were indeed foils. A thrust to the throat with a "regulation" weapon could be fatal, and to the best of my knowledge were never used in "fencing " matches during this period, even on the Continent where swordplace was more in vouge than in England. By the same token, we must remember that Victorian fencing sabres were a good deal heavier than the later 20th century sport sabres, and the full arm swing- particularly in the Hungarian school of sabre, was used through the turn of the century. As the fencing sabre lightened (mainly for safety reasons) cuts began to be done with the forearm through the 1950s. The precautionary bastardization of sabre resulted in an extremely light (safe)weapon in the 1960s, which only required a "flick" with thumb and forefinger, and very slight action of the wrist to score a touch. I learned to fence sabre in the 1960s when this style was considered proper, and the continued degression in this type of swordplay took the weapon from a theoretically atagonistic/dueling discipline to an agonistic sport not unlike tennis. Interestingly, in the past five years, there has been a return to slightly heavier bladed sabres, but then- the art has changed radically in other ways once electricfied sabres became common in sport tournaments.
Being a rabid fencer of all epee, foil and sabre-plus period weapons-and a classical French foil instructor, I having crawled onto my "hobby horse" in Burtonesque style, and I shall now dismount, and reiterate that I believe the celebrated bout was with foils. As related in an earlier email, Burton's favored Neopolitain style of foil would have dictated more attacks on the blade than the French school, which would logically explain the repeated disarms (due to beats) achieved by Burton.


Subject

Foil vs practice saber

Name

Marcus ([email protected])

Writen

5/24/02, 2:02 AM

I'll have to check that too but you have a lot of good information that usually doesn't come out in these discussions.

Practice sabers were common to all army's at that time and were used to acquaint them with the more realistic feel of swords. They were blunted and not sharpened. The antagonists wore padded jackets. This was true of sabers as well as cutlass's.

Great information. Thanks.


Subject

Re Burton's title of maitre d'armes

Name

Roark Mitzell ([email protected])

Writen

5/28/02, 9:11 AM

While rereading Burton's "Sentiment of the Sword" this past weekend, I noticed a reference by Isabel concerning Burton's title as a master of arms. The refernece is, as follows%3B "To this day," writes his widow, "the Burton une-deux, and notably the manchette (the upward slash disabling the sword arm and saving life in affairs of honour), are remembered%3B they earned him his brevet de pointe for the excellence of his swordsmanship, and he became a ma%EEtre d'armes."


Subject

Manchette

Name

Michael Ludwig ([email protected])

Writen

3/16/03, 11:45 AM

Hello,

Is the manchette only the rising back cut to the arm, or does it refer to an entire constellation of techniques for disabling the sword arm? In Burton's "New System..." he seems to present an entire system devoted to hitting the opponents sword arm. Am I correct in this understanding?

Sincerely,

Michael


Subject

New System of Sword Exercise

Name

Matt Easton ([email protected])

Writen

3/16/03, 1:18 PM

Link

Schola Gladiatoria

Hi all - what a great forum! Anyway - if you were not all aware of it already, here is some material from A New System of Sword Exercise for Infantry by Richard F. Burton:

http://ejmas.com/jnc/jncart_burtonnewsword_0200.htm

Matt Easton


Post a new message

Name

Email

Subject

Message

Optional Link URL

(Link Title)

This message is part of the message board for Sir Richard F. Burton on the Web, a web guide and directory to the African explorer, travel writer and translator of the Arabian Nights and the Kama Sutra.