Sir Richard F. Burton on the Web: Message Board

Return to Topics
|
Post a reply/new message
|
Return to Web Page

Post a reply/new message

Topic: What Advice Would Burton Give Us In The Present Situation?

Started by David H. Hawley on 10/10/01, 3:51 PM


Subject

What Advice Would Burton Give Us In The Present Situation?

Name

David H. Hawley ([email protected])

Writen

10/10/01, 3:51 PM


I mean in reference to dealing with -- or rather combatting -- the likes of Osama bin-Laden and his followers and supporters, especially those in Afghanistan. Burton knew something of Islam in general, I think it is safe to say, and even of radical Wahabiism (said by some to be the matrix from which the Taleban grew). And he knew the Afghans, or at least he knew the Pathans. I seem to recall that he listed them among those he considered "brave races." I believe he may have personally fought hand-to-hand against some of their near-kin. For my part I doubt he would counsel appeasement or docility in the face of the threat, as he seems to have been a reasonably bellicose man. But I confes I am only the most casual Burton scholar, and could be mistaken.


Subject

What Advice Would Burton Give Us In The Present Situation?

Name

Richard Leveson ([email protected])

Writen

10/12/01, 1:04 PM

Burton never fought in Afghanistan%3B the First Afghan War having come to its terrible conclusion just before his arrival in India late in 1842. My guess is that, brought to the present day for counsel, Burton would enquire deeply into the underlying causes and motivations of the conflict. Always one to see the "big picture" he would point out the need for even-handedness in foreign policy and, as always happened during his life, his opinions would be rejected and ignored%3B later to be proved absolutely and awfully right!


Subject

what advice....

Name

Michael Macciola ([email protected])

Writen

2/15/02, 12:35 AM

i guess it would depend on what age he was when this situation is unveiling and where he is living at the time. If he were mature in age then I believe Richard's comments are very appropriate. But what if Burton were 18-20 years old with a quest for knowledge, experience,identity and studying abroad? I have the feeling that he could have ended up in a similar position to John Walker Lindh. When I heard of this white man who was fighting with the Taliban,spoke Arabic and physically appeard to look the part the first picture that popped into my head was of Burton on one of his excursions to Mecca in disguise.


Subject

What Advice Would Burton Give Us In The Present Situation?

Name

Douglas Sunlin ([email protected])

Writen

5/28/02, 12:46 AM

Having served as ambassador or consul (?) in Jersusalem, Burton might have had some insights into how to reconcile Jew and Arab. If Was Palestine part of the Ottoman empire in that day? From my biography readings many moons ago, it seems to me that Jews were treated respectfully by the Ottomans. At the same time, I think the west had a preference toward the Jews, which Burton didn't agree with. I'm sorry, my books are in storage... Anyone?


Subject

Burton as a mediator?

Name

Richard Leveson ([email protected])

Writen

7/17/03, 7:31 AM

Damascus actually. Far from reconciliation, Burton interposed himself in some disputes between Jewish moneylenders there and local Arabs who borrowed from them. He seems to have taken the part of the Arabs and refused to allow his office as Consul to be used as a "collection agency" for the moneylenders, which his predecessors had done. Influential Jews in England were contacted and applied pressure at the foreign office which contributed to his ultimate recall. There were undoubtedly many other issues involved in this and, in fact, it has been pointed out that Burton was appointed over strenuous opposition by certain factions at the Foreign Office and his appointment was probably doomed from the start.




Subject

Burton's actions in today's world

Name

R. Dietrich ([email protected])

Writen

11/5/03, 7:17 AM

If Burton's activities with the Turkish irregulars he was working with during the Crimean War are any indication, I think Burton might very well have followed the approach actually used in Afghanistan - lots of special forces with a detailed knowledge of the region working in tandem with the local people in conjunction with conventional forces. As for Iraq, his comments would probably have been priceless.

P.S. Great site!


Post a new message

Name

Email

Subject

Message

Optional Link URL

(Link Title)

This message is part of the message board for Sir Richard F. Burton on the Web, a web guide and directory to the African explorer, travel writer and translator of the Arabian Nights and the Kama Sutra.