Sir Richard F. Burton on the Web: Message Board

Return to Topics
|
Post a reply/new message
|
Return to Web Page

Post a reply/new message

Topic: Burton's Diary

Started by Sean O'Shea on 8/14/01, 3:49 PM


Subject

Burton's Diary

Name

Sean O'Shea ([email protected])

Writen

8/14/01, 3:49 PM

I have read in an encyclopedia article and elsewhere that Burton kept a diary or journal during his adult life. Apparently, his wife burnt the diary after using it to prepare her biography of him. Does anyone have any information about this diary? How many volumes did it comprise? What did it discuss that his wife wanted the world to never learn about? I know Isabel was a devout Catholic and would have wanted to erase passages about his more violent and erotic adventures. But why would she burn the whole collection of personal writings?


Subject

Burton's Diaries

Name

Richard Leveson ([email protected])

Writen

8/15/01, 12:11 AM

Hello Sean

Burton was a compulsive note-taker and he did keep voluminous diaries which Isabel retained until her death in 1896 (according to Mary Lovell, who writes that they were in the inventory of effects sent from Trieste to London after Burton's death). What happened to them thereafter remains a mystery. On the other hand, Penzer, states categorically that Isabel burned all but one of these diaries, which he held in his own collection - his "gem". Others here may know of its present whereabouts.

As to what Burton's works discussed that Isabel would not have wanted widely known, I think you should read one of the Biographies, for Burton had controversial views and bizarre interests that covered so many fields: political, ethnological and anthropological, and Isabel, who tended to be a social snob and was very capricious in nature, never accepted many of these and often worked behind the scenes even during Burton's life to undo those actions of his which she considered "unfitting". The glorification of his name unto posterity was ever her aim, with hers attached, quite naturally enough.

See Lovell M.S. "A Rage to Live" W.W. Norton, New York, London 1998
and Penzer N.M "An annotated bibliography of Sir Richard Francis Burton KCMG"
Burt Franklin, New York 1970

These two individuals are at opposite poles in their opinion of Isabel!


Subject

Burton's Diaries - more information

Name

Richard Leveson ([email protected])

Writen

8/16/01, 9:28 AM

Hello Sean!

Your question made me revisit the points raised and I have more to add to what I just said. Thanks for stimulating me to do this!

(1) The diaries. Mary Lovell cites documents in the Witshire Record Office to show that these were in Isabel's posession at the time of her death, thus refuting the widely held claim that she burned them at Trieste. However, in her will, Isabel instructed that the diaries should be burned and her stated reason was "I will have no other Biography brought out". She presumably wanted her picture of Burton alone to be the one that passed to posterity. Absent the diaries and other insightful papers, any future biographer would face fearsome obstacles and enigmas, as indeed they have. The diaries were burned (save the one which came to Penzer, which was more of a notebook, actually) and this was clearly not done capriciously.

(2) Penzer's copy of Burton's diary (notebook) was destroyed, along with most of his Burton collection, by a bomb which hit his house in 1939.




Post a new message

Name

Email

Subject

Message

Optional Link URL

(Link Title)

This message is part of the message board for Sir Richard F. Burton on the Web, a web guide and directory to the African explorer, travel writer and translator of the Arabian Nights and the Kama Sutra.