|
Post a reply/new
message
Topic: With the SiteMaster's approval: Along with Burton - Stanley, Shackleton, Gordon
Started by Evan MacMurray on 8/7/01, 5:59 AM
|
Subject |
With the SiteMaster's approval: Along with Burton - Stanley, Shackleton, Gordon |
Name |
Evan MacMurray ([email protected]) | Writen | 8/7/01, 5:59 AM |
You have a site here commemorating one of the truly great of thought and Action. There really aren't that many others at or near His level : So why not the other few of the great of thought and Action - and also perhaps Alkibiades and Guevara too ?
Alcibiades had style, but was ignoble and failed in his efforts. Guevara had style, but labored in the service of an evil, emiserating ideology. Give me Burton any day.
|
Subject |
I think your denunciations of both, too extreme, Tim. |
Name |
Evan MacMurray ([email protected]) | Writen | 8/7/01, 11:47 PM |
Hi Tim,
I am not prepared to get into the debate of [[colon]] Socialism "Bad, Evil" - Capitalism "Good, Holy". I most emphatically disagree with you on Guevara - whom Jean Paul Sartre called ,"The most complete human being of our century".
Perhaps there are good reasons that I should accept your evaluation of Guevara Over Sartre's but until I find them I will concur with Sartre. I think it is because that you may not know enough of Ernesto Guevara De la Serna Lynch's life and written works that you say what you do about him. Even more than Robespiere 'the Incorruptable' Che Guevara was incorruptable. As to the ideology he 'served' - you might be surprised to know that he publically repudiated doctrinaire Communism, Russian Communism and Maoist Communism. So I would have to call into question HOW MUCH you know about Guevara? (Plus - I will argue that Capitalism is evil and Socialism is good- anyhow)
Or are you of that popular school of Dispute that defends its lack of complete information in this way [[colon]] "I know This Much about Guevara (or any personality they wish to superficially dispense with) and THAT is All I NEED to Know to establish that Guevara served Evil." -
I hope that you are more dilligent and Thorough than that in forming your opinions.
And about Alkibiades - I will take on his case as advocate as well.
But carefull here Tim - when Burton used to brow beat and intimidate Swineburne physically for his own amusement - and when he occasionally mistreated native porters(by contemporary standards to be sure) - admit that in looking for aspects in any human paragon's life that support our (political?) predjudices - we can weaken and somewhat diminish most any reputation.
We need to stay with facts that are so formidable in themselves that they need no interpretation to bend them to our point when we present them.
This Burton site you have here seems to draw a higher than usual calibre of net commentator -and I mean that to refer to my opponents in opinion on here as well as to those who may agree with me - [[colon]] To not allow this discourse to fall from that level - all of us have to try to restrain a natural tendency to be extreme in expressing our preferences and predjudices.
With good wishes,
|
Subject |
You're so right Evan |
Name |
Conor Walsh ([email protected]) | Writen | 8/8/01, 4:26 AM |
We do need to be moderate in the way we express our views.
Some fool I encountered elsewhere on the site started to accuse another contributor of being a "Nazi Gestapo Camp Commandant" (sic)!
The same person decided that I might be a woman - despite my name! - and started trying to hit on me with questions about my marital status!
I wish I could remember the idiot's name - can you, Evan?
Let's all think about what we write - it may haunt us for a while to come.
|
Subject |
SIMPLY POSTING%3DIN... |
Name |
BOB LOOMIS ([email protected]) | Writen | 8/14/01, 11:16 PM |
Im an admirer of Cpt Sir Richard, and stumbled onto this sight..simply adding a "hello' to those others who appreciate the colour of this man"s life. We should live so long and live so full as to wear our adventures so deeply on our face in our later years...my appreciation to the web-keepers.. Bob Loomis, Phoenix, Arizona
|
Subject |
Shackleton and Burton? |
Name |
C.A. Patterson ([email protected]) | Writen | 4/11/02, 10:04 PM |
I was drawn to this topic by the heading -- as I've only recently become aware of Shackleton's extraordinary feats, I'm interested to learn if he was influenced by Burton, whom I have been reading about for a long time. While the sites of their explorations were so vastly different, there are many similarities. Can anyone specify the links between the two?
|
Subject |
Got my finger on it |
Name |
Editor | Writen | 11/13/02, 11:13 PM |
I've finally figured out what's so irritating about Mr. MacMurray's response. It is this: his response casually supposes that nobody who had studied Guevara's life could hold the negative opinions I do. Such an opinion could only arise from stupidity. But, of course, many smart, well-read individuals think Guevara pernicious. Many also think him wonderful. I might be an idiot, but it's rude to assume so.
It's a common but regretable autodidact gnosticism to believe that truth is all about knowledge, that everybody would agree with you if they just read up. (The reading list is obvious too, of course.) And, if I may be permitted to impune MacMurray in return, a few dog-eared pro-Che books, the amusing ipse dixit of a dead leftist philosopher read on the back of one of those books (or perhaps in high-school?), showy demonstrations that you know somebody's name (though not "Swineburn"'s), and modernizing Greek transliteration married to a zest for capitalization that would make Queen Victoria blush, do not inspire confidence.
|