|
Post a reply/new
message
Topic: "Human Sacrifice Among The Sephardine [sic]"
Started by Dan Leeson on 6/5/01, 7:24 AM
|
Subject |
"Human Sacrifice Among The Sephardine [sic]" |
Name |
Dan Leeson ([email protected]) | Writen | 6/5/01, 7:24 AM |
Does anyone know of any book by Sir Richard Burton that bears this title? And should the answer be yes, will some kind soul comment on its contents?
Dan Leeson California
|
Subject |
"Human Sacrifice Among The Sephardine [sic]" |
Name |
Dan Leeson ([email protected]) | Writen | 6/5/01, 9:05 AM |
To clarify a little further, a manuscript said to be by Burton and with this title is about to be put up for sale in a London auction house, but I cannot confirm the provenance of this manuscript or even obtain verification that is really is by Sir Richard.
|
Subject |
Human Sacrifice Among the Sephardine |
Name |
Teresa Goudie ([email protected]) | Writen | 6/5/01, 12:58 AM |
yep - it's up for auction in London's Christies Auctions on Wed. June 6th. It's also known as the Eastern Jews. If you are interested, there will be a show on tonite in London called Newsnight at 10:30pm (London time) on the BBC (I think - it will be one of the terrestrial channels, anyway) which will talk about that manuscript. One of two men who have read the original manuscript will be on the show, as well as the man that I am a researcher for! Check it out!
|
Subject |
"the manuscript" |
Name |
nevillle hogan ([email protected]) | Writen | 6/5/01, 5:40 PM |
I have seen the "show" on Newsnight - BBC2 this evening. The sholar and the commentator were there. So was the lady at the head of the British Board who made the decison to sell - in order to raise funds for the acquisition of office accommodation. I don't know much about Burton, but it seems that he was -or became - a lunatic. The real debate is not so much about his apparent ravings but about the motivation of the British Board in flogging the manuscript in open auction. I think they are right to wish to expose these writings to public scrutiny. They will provide a further insight into the workngs of Burton's own mind, the Victorial mind-set on things Jewish and the nature of social hysteria. They will also serve to enlarge our understanding of the nature of the dislocation of historical consciousness which gives rise to atrocities called genocide. What do people think?
|
Subject |
Human Sacrifice among the Sephardine |
Name |
John ([email protected]) | Writen | 6/8/01, 4:02 PM |
Failed to sell at Christies. Bidding reached only %A3140,000 as against the reserve price of %A3200,000. Neville, if you "don't know much about Burton" recommend you become better informed before dismissing him as "a lunatic".
|
Subject |
Human Sacrifice, etc. |
Name |
Professor Geoffrey Alderman ([email protected]) | Writen | 6/10/01, 0:14 AM |
I appeared on the Newsnight programme and I am delighted at the outcome of the Christie's auction.
The Manuscript, which I have read in full, reveals Burton to have been a raving anti-semite, who believed the truth of the Blood Libel - which is still rampant, incidentally, in the Arab and Islamic worlds. Jews are forbidden by their religion from consuming blood of any sort. Burton was unhinged to say the least.
I fought - successfully - for the right of genuine scholars to read the MSS, but I cannot support its being made available to anyone to read.
|
Subject |
Burton and Censorship |
Name |
J. Patterson | Writen | 6/10/01, 6:15 AM |
Hmmm, I think it is time to come down out of that ivory tower there Doc (I presume). I do not know much of anything about this manuscript, but I find it difficult to believe that "genuine scholars" are more aware of their own biases or more capable of useful insight than anyone else. Furthermore, scholarship is a public endeavor, serving to benefit everyone (at least in a perfect world). Determining who can and can not read a particular work should not be left to anybody but the individual who is considering reading it. Give those outside of academia a little credit.
Sincerely,
J. Patterson
|
Subject |
Burton and Censorship |
Name |
J. Patterson | Writen | 6/10/01, 6:15 AM |
Hmmm, I think it is time to come down out of that ivory tower there Doc (I presume). I do not know much of anything about this manuscript, but I find it difficult to believe that "genuine scholars" are more aware of their own biases or more capable of useful insight than anyone else. Furthermore, scholarship is a public endeavor, serving to benefit everyone (at least in a perfect world). Determining who can and can not read a particular work should not be left to anybody but the individual who is considering reading it. Give those outside of academia a little credit.
Sincerely,
J. Patterson
|
Subject |
Human Sacrifice, etc. |
Name |
Professor Geoffrey Alderman ([email protected]) | Writen | 6/10/01, 9:54 AM |
The average person in the street knows little if anything of the circumstances of frustrated and disappointed ambition which caused Burton to write this work,or of its larger historical context (the situation of Jews in Arab lands in the 19th century, for example) or of the Blood Libel.
In civilised societies only qualified medical practitioners are permitted to carry out certain procedures, and to prescribe certain medicines. So it is, I'm afraid, with a small class of historical records: only qualfified scholars, whose motives are beyond question, should be able to read them.
In a perfect world I might agree with Mr Patterson. Sadly, this is not a perfect world.
And what else do you think goes in that category?
|
Subject |
Human Sacrifice, etc. |
Name |
Professor Geoffrey Alderman ([email protected]) | Writen | 6/10/01, 7:26 PM |
To answer Mr Spalding's question, I would say that governments are entitled to restrict access to archives on the grounds of national interest - for example, protecting the identities of those - and their families - who are responsible for national security. The danger of such information being made generally available, and thus getting into the hands of terrorists (for example),is too great a risk to run. Terrorist groups tend to have long memories, and such information might have to be restricted for a century, or even longer.
|
Subject |
Human Sacrifice, etc. |
Name |
J. Patterson | Writen | 6/10/01, 7:38 PM |
Professor:
I find both your analogies faulty. A piece of literature, no matter how controversial, does not directly affect the immediate well-being of an individual or group of people. Nor, is national security an issue. Granted not all indiviudals have good intentions and information can be used scary ways. However, those individuals are in the minority.
J. Patterson
"You have not converted a man because you have silenced him." John Morley, Lord (1838-1923), English writer, Liberal politician.
|
Subject |
Human Sacrifice, etc. |
Name |
Professor Geoffrey Alderman ([email protected]) | Writen | 6/11/01, 4:20 PM |
Mr Patterson has made my point for me. This particular piece of literature - Human Sacrifice - does indeed "directly affect the immediate well-being of an individual or group of people" - in this case the Jewish people.
Regarding the "bon mot" of Gladstone's biographer, John Morley, I have no wish to convert Burton: he is dead.
|
Subject |
Continuing Discourse |
Name |
J. Patterson | Writen | 6/12/01, 4:28 AM |
Professor Alderman (and others):
I know little beyond the basics of Blood Libel, such accusations made against the Jewish people, and I know nothing of the manuscript in question. I can understand how these types of accusations are offensive, slanderous, and perpetuate ignorance and bias. Yet, is this enough to ban, or severely limit access to a historical document? If so, there would be many more such documents in need of limited access. I am also wondering, without getting into details, how the manuscript compares with Burton's "The Jew, The Gypsy, and El Islam?" I seem to recall that this work was not very flattering to the Jewish people.
I am also curious to know why you thinking limiting access to the manuscript would make a difference if beliefs concerning Blood Libel are already prevalent in the Islam and much of the Arab world. Wouldn't free and open discourses more likely dispel ignorance concerning such issues, rather than "keeping it in the closet?" I am of the opinion that if something is restricted or socially/culturally "taboo", those malcontents among us only get more fired up%3B hence, the quote I included in my last post.
Finally, do you know where we can get transcripts of the television show you appeared on?
Thanks
J. Patterson
|
Subject |
Human Sacrifice, etc. |
Name |
Professor Geoffrey Alderman ([email protected]) | Writen | 6/12/01, 5:44 PM |
To Mr Patterson and others.
Mr Patterson and I will have to agree to differ. I assume that a transcript of the BBC TV "Newsnight" programme on which I appeared is available from the BBC in London%3B probably a fee will be charged.
I am "signing off" from this discussion, which I joined in order to explain my position. However, I do not think the story has ended, and I reserve the right to rejoin the debate if there are significant new developments.
I've often wondered how Burton, who seemed to have a wonderfully open mind about many, many subjects, could have lapsed into such wildly racist ravings as we find in "Wanderings in West Africa" and the evident anti-semitism in the work under discussion. Did these diatribes get worse with age? I suspect they did. One catches hints in "East Africa" and elsewhere, but it seems to have been after the Speke affair, and after his marriage, that he gave himself over wholeheartedly to the kind of crap that pandered to the worst prejudices of both Victorian society and his beloved Islam. As for this book on blood sacrifice, I can see that it would be profoundly offensive, and have no doubt that it is, but surely the best way to deal with it is to understand it in the context of Burton's life and times, not to treat it as if it were a virus that could infect our own. If, indeed, it is as dangerous as that, and our society is a vulnerable to belief in the Blood Libel as that, then we are in worse shape than I imagined. Chris
We should be wary of measuring the people of the past by the yardstick of contemporary views of right and wrong. Such judgements are fatal to understanding. The same can be said of the varied societies of today. Is it "wrong" to stone adulterers to death, as happens in certain countries today, or merely "wrong" from the Western liberal perspective? Does objective right or wrong exist at all? or must we invent an Aquinian "Law of God" or the modern artifice of "Crimes against Humanity" to underpin Nurenberg or the War Crimes tribunal in the Hague. These are serious matters which ultimately cannot be resolved. We simply "opt" for our angle on righteousness. I'm glad we do. But when it comes to ranting at a dead man forged in an age very different than this, we need to be careful if it's the truth we're after.
|
Subject |
Burton's offensive ideas |
Name |
Tim Spalding | Writen | 6/16/01, 12:59 AM |
As someone said, Burton was an equal-opportunity hater...
|
Subject |
Interesting the way 'analysis' of issues pro-Jewish and of those anti-Jewish, develope in the West |
Name |
Evan MacMurray ([email protected]) | Writen | 6/21/01, 0:51 AM |
We have this discussion of whether the unstable, infantile common man should be allowed to read the same inflammatory articles that the most 'stable' and of course un-infantile academician theoretically SHOULD be allowed to read.
Is there no one here to speak out against such claptrap and point out where it leads? The Medival Catholic Church thought parts of the Bible and church doctrine 'dangerous' for the common man to read and so withheld them. The Czars of Russia also forbade 'pernicious' books -[as those books WERE indeed dangerous to his autocracy] - the Nazis forbade the publishing and possession of certain books. It goes on and on in every deceptive repressive climate in history. Today we have the Politically Correct promulgated and supported by the establishment Media. Part of the Politically Correct opinion stance is, for instance, the the equation: Jews %3D Good. Palestineans(Arabs etc) %3D Bad.
Alderman is against the 'Blood libel' - he says Burton wrote through either being mad or becoming mad. So how is it, Alderman, that you will recommend forbidding us to read the substance of Burton's 'blood libel' (As if you were the Medival Catholic Church, the autocratic Czar of Russia, or a Nazi Gestapo commandant] BUT you cannot prevent us from reading the spurious and slanderous 'Protocols of the Elders of Zion' - the most notorious defamation of the Jews ever written? This slanderous pamphlet is available to everyone right now - and nothing could be more defaming than that article.
Will you claim that what ever this 'blood libel' Burton wrote of was MORE harmful to the Jews that the "Protocols of the Elders of Zion"? Not unless you are truly an idiot-savant fool - you won't.
So in your view or perhaps it is documentedly proven that all Burton wrote pf the Sephardim's practices was false and invidious - But are you or anyone Else going to decide that - the Burton stuff is that much Worse than the "Protocols of the Elders of Zion"?
Well if you are going to forbid that for the sake of 'the safefy of the Jews' [who it seems to me take care of themselves much more aggresively than Mexicans or Indians or Tasadays or Peruvian Indians] - then I want you to forbid ALL books that would be a threat to the safety of the Irish, and the Iraqis and the Palestinians and a few others too. You ready to do that?
The Jews have perhaps a little better moral history than most peoples - but there are still some things to criticize in them if we wish to look - and there are as many lies written about certain other peoples as well as the Jews. But one thing is certain - the press establishment of this country has a very strong Jewish ethnic presence participating in it. And whether due to that or Not - the Jews get one hell of a better press in this country than do the Palestinians. In fact it is almost impossible to characterize anything as Jewish policy or a traditional Jewish trait negatively in the US without being overwhelmingly and immediately attacked ones self - and most likely immediately being called a bigotted 'Anti-Semite'.
Read any Time - Newsweek - or major US newspaper account of the Jewish-Palestinian conflict - and then SUBSTITUTE the word Jew and Jewish for 'Arab' 'Muslim' or 'Palestinean' and then ask yourself if the the Jewish constituency in the US would tolerate their people being treated in the same negative accusatory terms -as 'journalism'.
I suggest that Alderman's plan to censor Burton's erroneous or subjectively flawed opinions about the supposed practices of the Sephardic Jews - is the same knee-jerk biased protectionism that is afforded anything relating negatively to Judaism in the the US. Other peoples and races have scurrilous books written about them that are available without restriction publically, - so what is Alderman doing proposing special censorship protectionism [through the suppression of historicaly significant expressions possibly false facts] about the Sephardim ? Isn't this really very transparent influence of the pro-Jewish Western societal Zeitgeist? Alderman is caught up in it - not because he is Really trying to be virtuous - but merely because he knows that he can APPEAR to be virtuous if he supports the most influential opinion-formers of these times.
You want to get along these days with no criticism and with a few 'attaboys' ? Simple - do as Alderman does. You come down on everything this way: Jews - Good! Arabs - Bad! Supporters of the Jews - Good! Criticizers of the Jews - Bad (and Liars!) Israeli - Good! Palestinian - Bad! "He spoke well of the Jews?" Well %3D Good then! "He spoke badly of the Jews(Burton)?" Well - Bad then! ..... So it's really all so simple to get your attaboys in this society. And it's all so simple to get your 'raving Anti-Semite' title too - just dare to say that the Jews have press influence and good press - then they gotcha: You're an Anti-Semite. This is what Alderman's censoring of Burton comes down to - although he would say that he is merely trying to censor dangerous historical lies.
|
Subject |
Burton and the Jews |
Name |
Conor Walsh ([email protected]) | Writen | 7/26/01, 5:05 AM |
Having just visited the recently opened Holocaust Gallery in the Imperial War Museum, London, may I say that there can be no real comparison in sane minds between the censorship of the Nazis and the suggestion before us.
Like many other contributors here I would ideally have liked to seen this repugnant manuscript made available as widely as possible in the interests of intellectual freedom. However I was fortunate enough to see Prof Alderman debating the Burton manuscript on Newsnight and have come around to his point of view: we do not live in a perfect world and this manuscript would allow the loons and crazies of our age to exploit the residual authority of RB's name (such as it is) to promote their hateful agenda.
Anti-Semitism is prevalent in Eaton Square, home of David Irving, as well as Arab countries (where the Protocols of the Elders of Zion is reprinted by mass-circulation newspapers and in other parts of the globe too, such as Mahathir's Malaysia and Mugbae's Zimbabwe. I for one wish to give proponents of this filth a clear message that it is meretricious and unacceptable. If it were not so dangerous it would be amusing.
There is clear evidence from emanations emitted in some of the things written here that Anti-Semitism in various forms and guises remains alive and unwell even among admirers of RB and as long as this reality persists it must be right for the responsible among us to seek to limit Anti- Semitism's expression and deny it material of whatever provenance.
Even at the time of Burton's writing the "Blood Libel" had been rightly refuted in general society, let alone in intellectual circles and there is only one real explanation for Burton's uncritical acceptance of this guff: he accepted Arab sources because they pandered to his own prejudices.
As a lover of Burton's panache and spirit I think we should be concerned, too, about the effect that mass publication of this noxious rubbish would have on his reputation. All his work would be tainted by association with this drivel and one's interest in the more delightful aspects of the life of this historical figure, linguist, ethnologist and traveller would be made to appear deeply suspect, quite inevitably. Christopher Ondaatje, by the way, came close to the reserve price on the manuscript at the auction, by the way: he said something made him hold his hand when he nearly had the thing%3B he said "Burton's reputation is more-or-less safe - for the moment".
Long may it remain so.
Prof Alderman's sensible compromise allows real historical research to continue while the hatemongers are barred at the gate. I don't see real grounds for objection and suggest some rather tendentious views have been expressed by those who claim to be aggrieved on the basis of intellectual freedom.
For myself I will continue to take interest in Burton, but in a rather more measured manner than I once did. For now my God has feet of clay.
|
Subject |
Burton's writings |
Name |
Richard Leveson ([email protected]) | Writen | 8/5/01, 1:16 PM |
The issue that started all of this, namely Burton's study of ritual practices amongst the Sephardim, was aired with extreme vigour (one could say quite equal vigour) early in the 20th. century (twentyone years after Burton's death), when there was a lawsuit between Alexander and Manners Sutton concerning the right to publish this very manuscript. (Times of London March 28th 1911, page 3 column 3).
Burton held dogmatic racial views which today would not pass censorship, but one statement of his (and this is here paraphrased because I do not have the original quote to hand) was " ... of all races, there is none to which I would more willingly belong than to the Jewish". I have read him extensively and have been amazed at the foresight and accuracy of many of his erudite writings%3B I have never known him to distort for the purposes of sensation%3B it was just not his style, his literary integrity was too great.
Those of you intrigued by some of the rather wild rhetoric apparent in this widening thread will gain some modern perspective by taking a look at the link below!
|
Subject |
Burton's writings |
Name |
Richard Leveson ([email protected]) | Writen | 8/5/01, 1:19 PM |
That link is www.normanfinkelstein.com
|
Subject |
Burton the sober narrator |
Name |
Conor Walsh ([email protected]) | Writen | 8/7/01, 4:04 AM |
I appreciate your efforts to do justice to RB but as he gave pseudo-scholastic credence to the suggestion that Jews ritually murdered Christians (in the Damascus Case, a Fransiscan Friar, no less, was the alleged victim) would you care to revisit your comment that "I have never known him to distort for the purposes of sensation%3B it was just not his style, his literary integrity was too great".
|
Subject |
The fervor of Conor Walsh's denunciation of any who would allow the Burton MS to be generally viewed. |
Name |
Evan MacMurray ([email protected]) | Writen | 8/7/01, 5:39 AM |
Conor,
Leaving out characterizations like 'loons' and 'crazies', 'hateful agendas', 'antisemitism' and 'filth' (and the like, but really Unnecessary adjectives) : what's the real deal here that you would have us accept?
1. Is it a sort of 'everyone knows' that all this stuff about the Sephardim had been disproven and is nonsence ?
2. Is it that, I, Conor Walsh, am not even going recognize or dignify even the thought of such a preposterous thing from anybody - because if anybody might want to research such a thing that Proves that they are an Anti-Semite ?
3. Or perhaps you have a Source Reference that Conclusively DOCUMENTS that Burton was either lying or being lied to and that he yet believed his lying source?
I hate to be so off the popular trend of sociological sentiment here Conor - but I am asking you Where Are Your Facts? Your Facts that Prove that Burton was mistaken in his allegations?
Personally I feel that he probably Was mistaken - but I think that an Emphatic Assumption that he was mistaken is both a little to trendy-sociologically correct and just a little too facile. So why not just the FACTS here? With no 'adjectives' or characterizations of who may be Anti-Semitic.
Is it Anti-Semitic in this decade to ask for facts that may or may not vindicate a segment of the Jewish people of something disapproved of?
You seem very sure - that Burton had no credible basis for telling or re-telling of the incidents he told readers of - Where are the Facts Conor?
(And I must invoke Godwin's Internet Discussion Law here: Godwin's Law applies primarily to those in a discussion, either characterizing their opponents as 'Hitler-like' or their opponents ideas as 'Nazism' : His law invoked in those cases is that - the discussion has deteriorated beyond all composed and logical ability to restore it to a mature and meanful level. I think we can extend Godwin's Law of using Nazism and Hitlerism to the using of Anti-Semitism as well. Remember when these are used they are NOT REAL POINTS OF ARGUMENT - they are ad hominems.)
With good wishes
|
Subject |
The facts of the Blood Libel |
Name |
Conor Walsh ([email protected]) | Writen | 8/7/01, 12:28 AM |
Evan, thank you for your good wishes.
They are returned.
As I understand your challenge, you wish me to prove that Jews are not in the habit of ritually killing Christians in order to utilise human blood in the baking of unleavened bread for the Passover Festival?
The fact that you make such a request means that it is not possible for me simply to appeal to your sense of reason and judgement, as one civilised person to another.
Please indulge me, therefore, in a little background history.
The Blood Libel we are dealing with was first invoked by Catholics in Norwich in England in the first half of the twelfth century and was associated with Anti-Semitic violence. It resurfaced repeatedly in Christendom, particularly during the most intense periods of persecution of Jews, despite being repudiated by at least four popes.
When the Blood Libel was resurrected (if you will pardon the term) in Damascus in 1840, following the disappearance of the Capuchin Friar Thomas (or Toma) a number of Sephardic Jews were taken into custody and tortured, and "confessed" to his murder.
The international outcry was enormous and the facts were voluminously recorded in most newspapers of the time. They are also readily accessible on the Net or in any decent history.
Sir Moses Montefiore, a Jewish philanthropist, travelled from England to the Ottoman Empire, secured the release of the accused persons and the issuing of a firman, or decree, by the Emperor, in October or November 1840 in terms of which he unconditionally acquitted the "suspects", declared the Blood Libel to be baseless, and confirmed the right of religious freedom of his Jewish subjects.
In juridical terms, the Emperor acted as a Court of Final Appeal and his verdict was legally speaking, final and conclusive. This is good enough for me.
As to why Burton accepted this disgraceful and disgraced myth, I can only respond "Corruptio optima pessimi".
Nonetheless the Blood Libel has since been used again %96 by Hitler, of course and others. It has been recounted as fact in media in Qatar, Palestine and Egypt (in the official daily Al Ahram, October 2000). Perhaps you will understand why, in the circumstances, I have no hesitation in linking the Blood Libel to extremist Anti-Semitism, and most especially to Nazism.
The information I have presented is freely available. Perhaps yours is not the sharpest pencil in the stationery cupboard, Evan%3B but the fact that you have been prepared to "keep an open mind" about such egregious nonsense and have found it acceptable to place an onus on me to refute its validity really does concern me.
I hope those who disseminate sophisticated critiques of the "Holocaust Industry" are aware of the intellectual range of many Anti-Semites.
I am not Jewish. I am a lawyer. I have been following the proceedings of the International Court on the Rwandan Genocide. Doubtless elevated minds will one day offer nuanced perspectives on the killing of more than a million people, on grounds of ethnicity, in the Great Lakes region.
Deplorably, perhaps, I prefer to express my sense of anguish and outrage rather than indulging in intellectualised metacommentaries.
Holocausts happen and will continue to happen where people of goodwill fall silent.
|
Subject |
Human Sacrifice among the Sephardim |
Name |
Richard Leveson ([email protected]) | Writen | 8/7/01, 1:31 PM |
Hello Connor
I shall do my humble best to "do justice" to Richard Burton quite of my own volition.
Geoffrey Alderman (a scholar?) attests that he has read this monologue and proclaims that it "reveals Burton to have been a raving anti-semite". This of course is HIS opinion. He then states that he would deny me the right (as a non-scholar) to read it for myself and so form my own opinion! How dare he!
Now, are you asking me to retract what I have said in support of Burton, a scholar of enormous stature, on the basis of statements like that, from a person with such an arrogant viewpoint? And if not, upon what other basis should I withdraw that which is my opinion and therefore freely open to contest?
Burton is refreshing because he looks at the good and the bad in EVERYBODY, and today he is unfashionable and disapproved because he permits himself to draw statistical concusions regarding the characteristics of race. These conclusions are, however, well-supported by argument, vast personal experience and incredible literary erudition. To read Burton today is a heavy undertaking indeed (and I have taken time to do this extensively) one spends an hour on a few pages and is often frustrated by the many references to facts and names, long since obliterated by time.
Connor, also please tell me, have YOU read the monologue? If not, will you please withhold opinions upon it until you have, just like me?
Kind regards Richard
|
Subject |
The Richards - Burton and Leveson |
Name |
Conor Walsh ([email protected]) | Writen | 8/7/01, 1:59 PM |
Dear Richard
I wouldn't dream, dear Richard, of asking you to retract a single one of your words, although having read extensively from the Burton oeuvre myself I rather feel your style makes his seem nimble.
Of course I haven't read the monograph but I have had sufficient access to secondary sources to have a good idea of its contents. I have great respect too for scholars like Professor Alderman and wouldn't dream of being so arrogant as to describe him as arrogant.
So, dear Richard, unless you can persuade me with something a little more substantial than your leaden sarcasm and pretensions to expert knowledge, I am afraid I will continue to pass opinion as and where I see fit.
But it is sweet of you to take the trouble to address me in this way.
Yours sincerely
Conor
|
Subject |
The Richards - Burton and Leveson |
Name |
Conor Walsh ([email protected]) | Writen | 8/7/01, 2:16 PM |
Dear Richard
I wouldn't dream, dear Richard, of asking you to retract a single one of your words, although having read extensively from the Burton oeuvre myself I rather feel your style makes his seem nimble.
Of course I haven't read the monograph but I have had sufficient access to secondary sources to have a good idea of its contents. I have great respect too for scholars like Professor Alderman and wouldn't dream of being so arrogant as to describe him as arrogant.
So, dear Richard, unless you can persuade me with something a little more substantial than your leaden sarcasm and pretensions to expert knowledge, I am afraid I will continue to pass opinion as and where I see fit.
But it is sweet of you to take the trouble to address me in this way.
Yours sincerely
Conor
|
Subject |
Human Sacrifice |
Name |
Richard Leveson ([email protected]) | Writen | 8/7/01, 3:42 PM |
Hello Connor!
That's fine, you answered truthfully what I'd assumed. You stick to your style and I'll stick to mine and you can have the last word!
Kind regards, Richard
|
Subject |
Taking Conor's commentary - "The Facts of Blood Libel' seriously - Very seriously. |
Name |
Evan MacMurray ([email protected]) | Writen | 8/7/01, 3:59 PM |
Conor,
I am sure that you want your latest commentary to be read and taken seriously. I am not sure if you want it somewhat analyzed and characterized which is also to take it seriously - but nonetheless I am going to analyze it here below. You say (pretty much to me I think ) in one place in your response that : : "As I understand your challenge, you wish me to prove that Jews are not in the habit of ritually killing Christians in order to utilise human blood in the baking of unleavened bread for the Passover Festival?"
You characterize That as what I asked you. I am surprised as a lawyer you rephrase a challenge as what is was, Not%3B to make it seem intentionally invidious. We are not refering here to 'Jews' generally as a whole group as you try to make it seem above. And we are not, of course, refering to an on-going 'habit' of child-slaughter carried on by Jews. We have ALWAYS in this discussion been refering to the question of whether Sir RFB had any good evidence to report that such a thing went on during a specificly witnessed period with a particular group of Sephardic Jews. So why the blanket invidious and untrue rephrasing of the question above?
All I attributed to you of was apparantly warranted predjudicial fervor. I did not attempt to demonize you. Yet even after invoking Godwin's Law - you in your un-jurudicial fervor were not able to Simply Stick to the Facts of your rebuttle- but still had to throw in the terms 'Anti-Semite' and 'Hitler' and 'Nazism'. Were you afraid the 'facts' of your argument would not carry enough emotional weight without such appeals to factional emotion?
And how does it help the 'facts' of your argument to offer your denigrating opinion of my lack of intellectual ability by saying to me... 'Perhaps yours is not the sharpest pencil in the stationery cupboard, Evan...' . Does that sort of ridicule somehow bolster your 'Facts' Conor? I don't think it is helpful in this discussion. In any event I will simply address your sarcasm but not reply in kind.
You go on to say to me ::
"The fact that you make such a request means that it is not possible for me simply to appeal to your sense of reason and judgement, as one civilised person to another. "
Your complaint above here ... that an opinion that questions yours in this issue (where the FACTS had not so far been stated! ) is not in ( -my view- ) an indictment of anybody's 'reason', 'judgement' or individual level of acculturated 'civilization'. You are not speaking of reason here but rather of your Expectation of supportive predjudice. Is it unreasonable to leave one's mind open to the possibility that members of ANY race may have at some time done something ethically reprehensible? Haven't the Serbs, the Tutsi, the Russians,the Thais, the Mongols and so on, all done things that are reprehensible? I would be willing to agree with you - that perhaps the Jews as a race ARE the kindest and most ethical of all .... and have NEVER done anything as reprehensible as other groups and races have. But in all good 'reason' - until the Facts are in on each accusation and each incident - why should you (or They) be given more than a 'Perhaps' on that? Are we totally in Orwellian times here were we must in the case of every invidious and reprehensible charge, come automatically down on the side of the Jews to be a 'good thinker'. That's not reasonable I think.
You inform me further that ::
""As to why Burton accepted this disgraceful and disgraced myth, I can only respond "Corruptio optima pessimi".
Here I must differ with and contradict you : As to WHY BURTON accepted this myth - you can't respond at - ALL - , with any facts or logic - as by your own admission you HAVEN'T READ Burton's MS! So your "....I can only respond.." etc., phrase is only rhetoric ( and rhetorical phrases thrown in for the effect of apparant justification of personal conclusions - are of course acceptable and I don't object to them - but once again Remember : Rhetorical phrases are NOT an ARGUMENT.)
You did not merely reply to me with Facts - but you sought to impugn my motivations and to imply that I probably have active predjudices. Where the FACTS are available - there is no need, Conor, to characterize your opponent as Anything personally - to establish the validity of your argument. Only when one is Unsure that he Has a good argument does one need to suggest that one's opponent may be tainted by this or that predjudice.
I will admit that you had the more difficult task .... in coming up with facts - than did I merely having to Ask whether there were facts. But where one was as ferverent as you in talking a position without First having stated the facts - I felt it was reasonable that I should ask for them.
This phrase of yours below of course gives you the chance to bring in the emotional buzz-word 'Anti-Semite' again into the discussion :
"I hope those who disseminate sophisticated critiques of the "Holocaust Industry" are aware of the intellectual range of many Anti-Semites."
You are allowed to 'hope' anything suggestive in any discussion of course - but how would you feel if I expressed 'hopes' in this discussion that 'you were not in the pay of covert Zionist Media manipulation groups' ?
I think that if I was to 'hope' such a thing that you would have the right to be justifiably outraged - because once again, Conor, THAT WOULD NOT BE AN ARGUMENT - it would only be a base insinuation.
I regard you as absolutely sincere and speaking here from your own personal conviction. I also think that you would wish to be fair in this discussion. But I think the emotional investment that you seem to have in this discussion [as evidenced by your inability to leave characterizing terms such as Hitler, Nazism and Anti-Semitism out of it] has in some of your phrases overcome your ability to keep strictly to the logic of the discussion.
It is true as you say, Conor, that ,"Holocausts happen and will continue to happen where people of goodwill fall silent."
But there is also a kind of gagging almost as corrupting - and that is, that when the ignorant, or people of ill-will bring up or insinuate untrue or harmful charges and opinions - that those who know the truth or who merely Object to them don't take them on - and refute them on the basis of the Facts head on - but simply try to Shut them up, by contumely and censure.
When you try to shut up people by merely CHARACTERIZING THEM as 'Hate-speakers' or as 'uncivilized' or by any insinuated ad hominem such as 'Anti-Semite' or as one lacking 'judgment' or 'reason' - then YOU, Conor, regrettably are allowing the suspicion to arise that such 'hate-mongerers' are summarily 'Shut Up' - because perhaps there is somethingTO what they say - that it might be true! And can't be easily refuted.
It PROMOTES Predjudice to try to Silence its expression with law or censure. Take it head on with the Facts and you will beat it - and leave the characterizations out of it.
[Personally I will go head to head logically with anyone who impugns the Jews as a particularly harmful or unhelpful race towards the rest of humanity. But I won't go along with any accusations being swept under the media-academe rug about any group.]
As to the evidence you brought forward : I think it impressively supports the likelihood that the charges against that group of Sephardim were false and predjudicial. If there were even more conclusive evidence I would like to see that as well.
And such Evidence should not be HIDDEN from public view - but should be put along with Burton's thesis taking each of Burton's charges Point by Point for ALL to see. This hiding of the MS does nothing but raise suspicions.
With good wishes,
|
Subject |
Burton and the Blood Libel |
Name |
Conor Walsh ([email protected]) | Writen | 8/8/01, 0:37 AM |
Evan having to read your latest turgid screed was onerous - please don't expect me to respond to it in great detail.
Suffice to say two things:
Firstly, your strictures against me for using certain accurate terms, such as Anti-Semitism and Nazism ring a little hollow. I was not the first to use such wildly emotive language: you were, in your posting of the 21 June. Perhaps you would apply Godwin's Internet Discussion Law and your own similarly marvellous principles of ratiocination to your own postings to avoid a charge of, if not hypocrisy, then at least airheadedness. Who first "demonized", "smeared", "ridiculed" if not you?
Secondly, you appear to lack the intellectual honesty to accept that Burton's espousal of the Blood Libel in relation to the Sephardim of Damascus does indeed connect him with the chain of similar accusatins made over a thousand years of history. If one accepts the validity of Burton's case one is obliged to revisit every similar accusation. And having re-read your posting of the 7 August it is quite clear that you felt it was necessary to refute the Blood Libel ab initio. You obviously lack the courage to accept the implications of the challenge you posited:
"I hate to be so off the popular trend of sociological sentiment here Conor - but I am asking you Where Are Your Facts? Your Facts that Prove that Burton was mistaken in his allegations?"
In any event, Evan, I am so pleased that you have been persuaded by my owm meager efforts that "the likelihood that the charges against that group of Sephardim were false and predjudicial". This makes my intervention worthwhile.
For the record, I am not in the pay of Zionist lobbies etc. It flatters me that you could consider my contributions to be worthy of pay. Motives you might find less intelligible impel me I am afraid.
And turning to you, dear Richard, I am pleased to accept your decision to surrender your poition as arbiter of - how did you put it in your first posting? - "some of the rather wild rhetoric apparent in this widening thread".
Each of us has formed his own opinion of the other's attitude to style as well as his sense of priorities in respect to other, more important matters.
I don't claim the right of last word. Doubtless the debate will continue to run. Doubtless it will be necessary for someone else to refute the Blood Libel in response to questions from another "fresh mind" before too long.
|
Subject |
"Evan having to read your latest turgid screed was onerous - please don't expect me to respond to it in great detail." Conor Walsh |
Name |
Evan MacMurray ([email protected]) | Writen | 8/8/01, 2:47 AM |
Well the first line of Conor's last response to me - as title above - pretty much tells us who is who here, folks%3B and who is willing to address the other's points without ad hominem.
I reserve the right - if I have inclination and am sufficiently incapable of doing anything creative at a later time to make malicious ad hominem fun of Conor's letters . - That is to linguistically and logically kick his ass while holding him up to the most amusing contumely. But not now, not now. I should at least for a time set the example in carrying out my own recommedations of emotional self-restraint as we express ourselves in these commentaries.
_________________________________________________________________________________ One false allegation of Conor's should be exposed however -
AS in his/her? previous response Conor knowingly misrepresents what he knows - that I said -
I reprint in quotes below what I said to him in my last, concerning his insistance on bringing up logically non-substantive defaming buzz-word terms of denigration such as - 'Anti-Semite' , 'Hitler' and 'Nazism' [which invoking Godwin's Law of Internet Debate I asked him to refrain from doing] -
From my Previous commentary on his Commentary - . -
[Quote from Evan] "This phrase of yours [The 'phrase' I speak of is below from Conor's previous commentary post] below of course gives you the chance to bring in the emotional buzz-word 'Anti-Semite' again into the discussion :
[what I am speaking of above, from Conor's previous commentary to me - Quote from Conor] "" I hope those those who disseminate sophisticated critiques of the "Holocaust Industry" are aware of the intellectual range of many Anti-Semites.""End Quote
[Evan Replies to that -] 'You are allowed to 'hope' anything suggestive in any discussion of course - but how would you feel if I expressed 'hopes' in this discussion that 'you were not in the pay of covert Zionist Media manipulation groups ?
I think that if I was to 'hope' such a thing that you would have the right to be justifiably outraged - because once again, Conor, THAT WOULD NOT BE AN ARGUMENT - it would only be a base insinuation.' - - End quote from Evan's Reply.
Then Conor comes in - in his last commentary with this denunciation of me in the form of a 'Denial' of what was NEVER said about him - but only used as example to counter his Anti-Semite statement above -
Here is CONOR's 'Denial' of what was NOT said - to make it appear as if I accused him in that way - Quote from Conor] ""For the record, I am not in the pay of Zionist lobbies etc. It flatters me that you could consider my contributions to be worthy of pay. Motives you might find less intelligible impel me I am afraid.""End Conor Quote
My actual NEXT LINE of Commentary after giving the example above of his 'Denial' of what was NEVER SAID Was this - [Quote Evan's NEXT LINE to Conor%7D 'I regard you as absolutely sincere and speaking here from your own personal conviction. ' End Quote of Evan's Next line to Conor.
So! what WAS the point of Conor's pseudo-'Denial' Then? What accusation of mine did he have to Deny?
Most of us are astute enough to see what sort dissembling is being tried here - I think.
_______________________________________________________________
To put the Tin Hat on what seems to be descending into a squabble of mutual recrimination - I think it is worth while RePrinting the end of my Last commentary to Conor that he/She? is complaining about [Ending Quote from Evan's 'open letter' that Conor is complaining about Quote from Evan ] -
'When you try to shut up people by merely CHARACTERIZING THEM as 'Hate-speakers' or as 'uncivilized' or by any insinuated ad hominem such as 'Anti-Semite' or as one lacking 'judgment' or 'reason' - then YOU, Conor, regrettably are allowing the suspicion to arise that such 'hate-mongerers' are summarily 'Shut Up' - because perhaps there is somethingTO what they say - that it might be true! And can't be easily refuted.
It PROMOTES Predjudice, to try to Silence its expression with law or censure. Take it head on with the Facts and you will beat it - and leave the characterizations out of it.
[Personally I will go head to head logically with anyone who impugns the Jews as a particularly harmful or unhelpful race towards the rest of humanity. But I won't go along with any accusations being swept under the media-academe rug about any group.]
As to the evidence you brought forward : I think it impressively supports the likelihood that the charges against that group of Sephardim were false and predjudicial. If there were even more conclusive evidence I would like to see that as well.
And such Evidence should not be HIDDEN from public view - but should be put along with Burton's thesis taking each of Burton's charges Point by Point for ALL to see. This hiding of the MS does nothing but raise suspicions.
With good wishes,' [ End Quote of Evan's last commentary to Conor]
[ Alas ! OK - Conor. Some people you just can't please. You married, Conor ??]
|
Subject |
Please, Evan, don't kick my ass! |
Name |
Conor Walsh ([email protected]) | Writen | 8/8/01, 4:03 AM |
If this is the very best you can do to take issue with me on this topic through the closest analysis of which you are capable - I pronounce myself well content.
|
Subject |
Please, Evan, don't kick my ass! |
Name |
Conor Walsh ([email protected]) | Writen | 8/8/01, 4:13 AM |
If this is the very best you can do to take issue with me on this topic through the closest analysis of which you are capable - I pronounce myself well content.
Hello again Conor!
Hey, man, you seem to have an awful lot of time on your hands for a lawyer ... I think you really ought to get back to work so you can bill some hours. You and Evan will never see eye to eye and there's no point in getting so darned personal with him (or me either) just because of that! My bet is that most of the folks watching this thread have become bored stiff.
Shalom! Richard Leveson
|
Subject |
But you promised me the last word |
Name |
Conor Walsh ([email protected]) | Writen | 8/8/01, 10:02 AM |
Dear Richard
Cet animal est tres mechant, Quand on l'attaque il se defend.
I will always find time for issues like this%3B I wish more people who are supposed to take a professional interest in justice would.
Shalom haver
Conor
I find the whole debate on whether to make the work available or not hilarious. I'm almost certain that the prospective infliction of censorship would be for the benefit of the American population. I can't see how an anti-semite can become more of an anti-semite (I suppose it might not be impossible to consider it might spark up a few born-again anti-semites), the rest of the people know better. I really don't believe that in much of the world, with the unfortunate exception of some Islamic countries, people really care whether someone is Jewish or not and it would be incredible to suggest that someone would believe the supposed allegations that are made in Burtons work.
I will make this humourous, infantile and warped to get my point across. If this messageboard was part of some cheaply made american horror flick the closest movie to it would be Gremlins. Just think of all those innocent social retards who live in America and support the likes of the KKK. I'm sure they would think that there is some truth in the supposed contents of the work. The more you make of this the more people will believe there is some truth to it. Lets just hope there isn't anyone out there who thinks that the Jews aren't allowed to consume blood because they will mutate before their eyes into some type of monster, like in Gremlins!
I'd also like to remind you that one humourous definition of an expert is 'someone who knows more and more about less and less' - Isn't that correct Prof.?
Can you now appreciate how silly the whole debate on this is?
|
Subject |
Cliches and those who use terms like 'sucks' and social 'retard' (sic) |
Name |
MacMurray ([email protected]) | Writen | 4/14/02, 2:45 PM |
Those who disparage particular debates or invidious debates generally, - are those psychologicaly impaired sorts who can't cheerfully and calmly confront verbal disagreement and conflict. Of course the type is so prevalent as to be commonly legion. In the vein of asking, as the pseudonominous W.Isdom does ,"Can he she now appreciate" how silly her whole complaint is - in complaining about particular disputes on-subject or general disputes on-subject ? Disputes on issue may clarify an issue(but sometimes not). Complaints about a particular dispute clarify nothing except the psychological condition of the complainer. Telling us that this or that 'sucks' only reveals the lack of linguistic ability of the writer who is forced to use such slang terminology to express her general complaint.
|
Subject |
'pseudonymous' - unrevised computer typing and spellcheck |
Name |
MacMurray ([email protected]) | Writen | 4/14/02, 2:59 PM |
pseudonymous - [usually don't do any checking - but I reread this one.]
From: [email protected] %7C Block Address %7C Add to Address Book To: [email protected] Subject: failure delivery Content-Length: 1619 Message from yahoo.com. Unable to deliver message to the following address(es).
%[email protected]%3E: 64.32.182.141 does not like recipient. Remote host said: 550 5.1.1 %[email protected]%3E... User unknown Giving up on 64.32.182.141.
--- Original message follows.
Return-Path: %[email protected]%3E Message-ID: %[email protected]%3E Received: from [216.195.148.95] by web14606.mail.yahoo.com via HTTP%3B Mon, 15 Apr 2002 10:39:39 PDT Date: Mon, 15 Apr 2002 10:39:39 -0700 (PDT) From: Evan MacMurray %[email protected]%3E Subject: Psychological impairment To: [email protected] _____________________________________________________________________
%3ENo surprise -%3C
|
Subject |
More checking : Both Walsh |
Name |
MacMurray ([email protected]) | Writen | 4/16/02, 0:39 AM |
Both of the 'Posters' who reacted with such outrage at releasing anything Burton may have said that was critical of Jews - have turned out to be imposters with phony email addresses. These are the sort of 'posters' who fear to be contacted or identified.
Message from yahoo.com. Unable to deliver message to the following address(es).
[email protected] : ('Conor Walsh's' address.) Sorry, I couldn't find any host named b.com. (%235.1.2)
--- Original message follows.
Return-Path: %[email protected]%3E Message-ID: %[email protected]%3E Received: from [216.195.147.3] by web14608.mail.yahoo.com via HTTP%3B Mon, 15 Apr 2002 22:21:14 PDT Date: Mon, 15 Apr 2002 22:21:14 -0700 (PDT) From: Evan MacMurray %[email protected]%3E Subject: Checking phony email addresses from Burton site To: [email protected] MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: multipart/alternative%3B boundary%3D"0-105020583-1018934474%3D:3920"
--0-105020583-1018934474%3D:3920 Content-Type: text/plain%3B charset%3Dus-ascii
|
Subject |
Captain Sir Richard Francis Burton's writings. |
Name |
Marcus ([email protected]) | Writen | 5/21/02, 5:09 PM |
Burton was a very well rounded person for his time but most of the people of today aren't. Let me point out that his wife was much more likely to have "ghost" written his anti-semetic books.
Take a look at some of the information that is being made available and look at the way it is written and especially in any "French" consulate info that doesn't use the Gregorian calender dates. It's highly unlikely that they would send information to their mother country in a form that they would have to translate the date back into the Gregorian calender.
Burton was a lot of things but he was no fool as some of those "pseudo Burton" books and quoters have him being.
While I think that everyone has the right to believe what they want, I also believe that they should have the guts to say they don't know or it's their opinion and not a dead persons.
|
Subject |
A little history lesson for that racist streak up your back. This was on the History Channel on May 29 in the WWII history area. |
Name |
Marcus ([email protected]) | Writen | 6/1/02, 5:02 AM |
On this day in 1942, on the advice of Nazi propaganda minister Joseph Goebbels, Adolp Hitler orders all Jews in occupied Paris to wear an identifying yellow star on the left side of their coats.
But Goebbels was not the first to suggest this particular form of isolation. "The yellow star may make some Catholics shudder," wrote a French newspaper at the time. "It renews the most strictly Catholic tradition." Intermittently, throughout the history of the papal states ( the territory controlled by the pope in central Italy ) Jews were often confined to ghettos or made to wear yellow hats or yellow stars.
Of course for the supersticious or racists this will not change your view. But for the rest it should give some credence as to who really wrote the material they are now trying to pass off as Richard Burtons. Isabel as a devout Catholic was just writing what she thought and what she wished he would have thought.
I have read the postings between these three protangonists. I am sorry to admit I am embarrassed with all three. The issue is the life of Burton. In pursuing this all three have digressed and obtruded their own personal platforms, their own personality and their own selected 'facts' into the argument as proof in rebutting the others. No wonder there can be no agreement!
In law, medicine or science, the general rule for reasonable people is to 'keep the main poin the main point'. The Life of Burton is the common starting point. His intentions can never be determined as a fact without consulting him%3B which, since his death, is not practicable. You may agree (with Maimonides) that intellect is action, and therefore his writings are portents of his actions and therefore his intellect. But this is deductive logic, whose conclusions have no right of certainty because their premisses have no right of acceptance.
Debate is useful if the protagonists bring the moderation of reason to the debate. The proper purpose of debate is understanding. And Burton's life is certainly worthy of examination with understanding as its end. His intentions (and those of his wife) are topics of conjecture, and should properly be portrayed in that tentative light with all due proprietry toward the dead, (tending toward generosity) owed by truly educated humans. Lives are not footballs to be kicked around.
The subject is a meaningful and human subject. Conclusions from this life should be tinged with the intellectual modesty commensurate with our remoteness from the genuine facts of the case. This correspondence ought not be matters of opinion, but matters of fact. To be kind is more important than being smart.
Morrison O.G.T. Lee (Australia) Seoul, South Korea.
|
Subject |
Embarrassed or maybe debate versus arguing. |
Name |
Marcus ([email protected]) | Writen | 7/22/02, 12:02 AM |
I think that whether or not someone has a particular view is not as essential in a debate as in an argument. A debate is where the merits or facts are discussed and a logical outcome is possible though not always. An argument is where there is two or more divergent viewpoints and they are argued with or without facts to support them, an emotional debate let's say instead of logical as in the case of the real debate.
As in the case of Sir Richard and Isabel there can be no certainty as to the real information, only implied or logical assumptions based on they're known public and private writings.
I think though that few of us can relate to them other than on our own personal level as that period of time is completly gone now. Almost everything they both went through is very abstract to us today. His "racism" was not only different but more plausable then rather than now.
But you are right that some of these folks here are using Sir Richard and Isabel to further their skewed views.
|