Sir Richard F. Burton on the Web: Message Board

Return to Topics
|
Post a reply/new message
|
Return to Web Page

Post a reply/new message

Topic: Burton"s trip to Salt Lake City.

Started by J. Lee Bonham E.D. on 4/23/01, 12:18 AM


Subject

Burton"s trip to Salt Lake City.

Name

J. Lee Bonham E.D. ([email protected])

Writen

4/23/01, 12:18 AM

When Burton made his trip to Salt Lake City Utah to visit with Brigham Young he spent several months in the United States before appearing in St. Joseph, Missouri to take the Platte River trail across the plains to South Pass, and Fort Bridger.
I am looking for sources of information relating to this part of his trip, What part of the U.S. was he in, who did he visit with etc.
I would appreciate any information I can get and would be pleased to discuss my project with others that might be interested. E.mail will be replied to.


Subject

Burton and the Eastern US

Name

J. Patterson

Writen

5/2/01, 8:44 PM


In an article entitled "Greatest Victorian Explorer meets the Old West" (True West Magazine, June 1994), Matthew Riley summarizes the highlights of Burton's North American journey. Included in the article are numerous ideas and theories (proposed by Rice, Brodie, etc.)concerning Burtons time in the eastern US after leaving New York. there is nothing new here, but thought you might like the reference if you do not already have it.

Happy Trails,

J. Patterson


Subject

Burton and the Mormons

Name

Mark Blanchard ([email protected])

Writen

5/25/01, 3:50 AM

Dear Messirs Bonham and Patterson,

How timely I found your recent posts to be!

I'm a former case officer with the Central Intelligence Agency who is currently researching a book on Burton's 1860 overland trip from an espionage perspective. I look forward to reading Mr. Riley's article, which I was not formerly aware of and I confess I've not yet read Brodie's bio since I couldn't abide her psycho-babble approach to Joseph Smith and feared she would do more of the same with Burton. But for my current research I now find that I have to read it, so it's on my shelf and I shall dive in right after I re-read Rice and post the updates of what I find in both in reference to this question once I feel I have a handle on the most likely scenario.

Here's my spook-biased theory that my research is attempting to substantiate. See what you think.

I postulate that Burton's Utah trip (like his voyages to Arabia, Harar and Central Africa) was made primarily at the Crown's command and secondarily for the purposes of adventure or exploration. In other words, I believe he was on an official undercover diplomatic mission to forge (or at least put forward) a secret agreement between Brother Brigham Young and England regarding Mormon neutrality in the pending war between North and South. (I suspect this was Brodie's theory too, but I'll have to read her to be certain.)

Remember that in 1860 The Civil War was brewing and during that war England and France both initially leaned toward the South, hoping that the Union would fall. If it did, then the speculation is that England could pounce down from Canada (don't forget '54-40 or fight!')before France could sneak up from Mexico.

I postulate in my book that the deal was this...if Brigham Young agreed to stay out of the War and not aid the Union and later ally himself to the English interests in the West, then those the Queen might recognize his independent nation of Deseret which the Union had previously crushed in the aborted Mormon secessionist rebellion of 1857. (A rebellion which, ironically, was put down by the Confederate hero of Shiloh, Albert Sidney Johnston.)

Yes, I know that Burton certainly had a vested intellectual interest in penetrating these forbidden places and rounding out his triology of trespass, but I think the Foreign Office saw great 'practicality' in his undertaking the mission just then. Yes, Sir Dick knew he could get a book out of the Mormon trip because he got books out of everything. I think his stated goals were mere ancillary reasons providing a convenient cover. I think the primary reason was the expansion of the British Empire, on which the sun was still rising in the '50's and '60's.

In preliminary support of my hypothesis, I cite the fact that Burton was a successful undercover spy in the Indian Army during his time in Sub-continent and shortly after Utah he switched into 'overt' out-to-pasture mode at the consulate in Fernando Po, in which status he remained for the rest of his life. For that period of his service between India and California, he merely continued his work with a slightly deeper cover

Now, assuming for a minute that I'm right, how does this apply to the 1860 trip? Well, many scholars have found it odd that Burton was no sooner back in England from the Lake Regions than he unexpectedly heads back out for America while Grant and Speke go back to Africa to prove him wrong.

Stranger still, when Burton arrives in the US he makes a few token appearances on the east coast, hobbnobbing with the power brokers, then he DISAPPEARS for several months, presumably going to the South where he met with Confederate leaders before turning up again in St. Jo and beginning his voyage West.

This trip he undertakes, observing and describing everything with that classic microscopial detail that we love from him, then he gets to Salt Lake, meets ol' Brigham who he describes in glowing terms, meets the notorious Porter Rockwell (also described as a square pardner), he goes to a few parties and leaves for California. That's it.

In short, NOTHING MUCH HAPPENS on the whole damn trip. Some voyage of exploration, eh?

Strangest of all, the hyper-observant, uber-critical, proto-ethnologist that Burton is ends up singing nothing but praise for the Mormons and all their strange religious practices. Nor does he appear to dig much into the subject of polygamy which was presumably one of the reasons for his going, was it not? Where is the penetration the sanctum sanctorum of Salt Lake City, the probing of hidden mysteries, the unearthing of scandalous scuttlebutt that the real Richard Burton would have written? It simply isn't there.

So why isn't it there? I think it isn't there because Burton didn't want to offend Brother Brigham or his kingdom. The secret Anglo-Mormon 'agreement' (if it existed) was still in effect in 1861 when the book was published and the outcome of the war was still in doubt. The French were on the move in Mexico and if the Confederacy were to win, Yankee manifest destiny would have been stunted for good. So Brigham keep the Mormons out of the war, didn't oppose the 'Americats' or aid them either and everybody sat back to watch the way the wind blew.

Anyway, that's my theory. Please do tell me what you think and point out any corroborating or contradicting pieces of information if you know of them.

Regards,

Mark Blanchard


Subject

Burton's visit to Salt Lake etc.

Name

To Mark Blanchard

Writen

5/29/01, 3:02 PM

Just found your message and want to correspond with you regarding your ideas concerning the period between the landing at Halifax and reappearence at St. Joseph. I have been researching z similar idea.This is the reason for my posting for information.
I have turned up a couple of pieces of information that may be pertinent. First if the trip to visit Brigham Young was planned as more than "cover" why is there no record of Burton making any attempt to visit with the Chouteau family in St. Louis.Note that they and other St. Louis fur traders would have been the best sources of information on the overland trail. I could find nothing in the Chouteau Papers to indicate that he met with them.
I had not thought of a possible involvement with Brigham Young in the up-coming Civil War but it certainly is a possibility considering the angle of the Mormon Battalion and its activities.
My thinking has centered around the idea of plots and counter plots in New Orleans and possible negotiating deals for munitions, and blockade runners for cotton.
Nice hearing from you.
Lee Bonham



Subject

Burton in America

Name

Christopher Dickey ([email protected])

Writen

6/2/01, 4:50 AM

Link

ChristopherDickey.com

I see there are many of us who are interested in those months between the time Burton landed in Halifax and his reappearance in St. Joe. I was first struck by this historical lacuna when I read Rice's biography about a decade ago, in which he suggests that Burton probably was spying. But to what end, precisely? I have been gathering string on this subject ever since.
I think it's worth keeping in mind that Burton was in pretty bad shape both physically and emotionally after his journey to the Lake Regions. Speke, who'd betrayed him, was the darling of London, and especially of the Royal Geographic Society. Burton couldn't get the funding to go back to Africa. He was scrambling to write his book about the subject, but this long and rambling narrative did not reach any definitive answer to the great question of the day: where was the source of the White Nile? Nobody wanted to give money to Burton to go prove Speke wrong, which is what he seemed to want to do. So Speke and Grant headed back toward Ujiji, and Burton -- at precisely the same time -- headed West with Steinhaueser.
Fawn Brodie does indulge in a lot of psychobabble, but she's probably right to suggest that Burton was pretty damned depressed by that Spring of 1860. In addition to the traumas with Speke over the course of the winter, his romance with Isabel had run up against the rock of her father. He was also blighted by disease, including secondary syphilis, and he was almost 40 years old. In fact, his great exploring days were over, and this fact may have begun to dawn on him.
All of this could make Steinhaueser's proposition that they drink their way through the USA more credible on its face. But the itinerary we know of is not really a drinker's journey, and, yes, it was a much more plausible mission plan if the two men were spies.
Clearly Britain had an enormous interest in the future of the United States, and especially the future of the South. Most of the cotton spun in the Lancashire mills came from Dixie. But it's not clear that Burton's sympathies, or those of his patrons, would have been with the Secessionists. His greatest supporter at the RGS, and one of his closest friends, Richard Monckton Milnes, was also one of the few powerful voices in parliament opposing British support of the South when war broke out in 1861.
The hypothesis about Burton being on a mission to seek Mormon neutrality is interesting, and I look forward to reading your book. But my guess is that the trip out West was something of a failed adventure. He had tried to make arrangements to do a little Indian fighting. I suspect he was hoping to write a sort of true-life Wild West best seller, which were much in vogue whether true or not. But Burton, bound as he was to factual reporting, just didn't see enough action. (Indeed, it's amazing how boring many of Burton's books really are. Reading them is much less interesting than reading about them, which may be one reason so many biographers have sought to mine the nuggets from the mire of detail.) Having missed the action with the Indians, Burton's fall-back plan was the book on the Mormons, whose faith bears rather interesting parallels to Islam. All the while, we can safely presume he was reconnoitering, but the more I look at "City of the Saints," the less interesting I find that section of the trip.
His peregrinations in the East and South, of course, are a different matter. Burton and Steinhaueser land at Halifax, buy a Newfoundland puppy (I've never been sure why, and wonder if it wasn't really a Lab) and journey to Boston, the hotbed of abolitionism. Then they go to New York, where Burton visits his American publisher, who's about to bring out the U.S. ediiton of "Lake Regions," and they run into another famous African explorer who's been traveling up the Congo. After that, it's on to Washington D.C. for a meeting with the secretary of war, who, we know, was secretly arming the secessionists. And then comes the big gap in the chronology between Washington and New Orleans. Steinhaueser goes back to Europe, perhaps to report on their findings, and dies. Burton heads West.
Anybody else have anything on the part of the trip between Washington and New Orleans? My imagination has filled in quite a bit, but my documentation is thin.
Chris








Subject

Richard Burton and the Mormons

Name

Mark Blanchard ([email protected])

Writen

6/2/01, 4:00 PM

Dear Lee and Chris,

I'm happy to see that we have several minds probing this issue. Perhaps we'll be able to get at some truth (or a reasonable facsimile thereof) if we keep at it. I'm going to focus on the Mormon aspect of the trip since it jives with my book (historical fiction of the Flashman type) and I'll make sure to update here regularly with what I find. Let me tell you some of the strange things I've noticed in the past week or so.

First, I should respond to why Burton didn't bother to chat with the St. Louis furtraders mentioned. He probably didn't think they had anything novel or unique to contribute to his mission, that's why. That's because the overland regions were no longer mysterious unexplored territories -- that narrow strip of land was a well-documented continental superhighway over which hundreds of thousands had passed and Burton was not out to explore or sightsee or indian fight. He was there to get to Salt Lake City as expeditiously as possible so he took the fastest, most direct route and didn't really pause much along the way. Except in very weird places.

Consider these interesting tidbits I've discovered. Burton leaves by direct stage out of St. Jo on Aug 7th with not one stage but in TWO coaches in highly unusual sort of coach for hire kind of an arrangement. He does not name the companions who travel in this second stage, but he does name Lt. James Dana and wife who go with him in the first stage. These two stages travel across the plains non-stop TOGETHER for the next five days. Then they start slowing down, again together, pausing every night to rest before continuing the next day. On this trip they pause at several forts, chat casually with the soldiers, but never once deviate from their trip to visit or hunt or try to scare up an indian fight. It's straight through all the way.

Then they get to their final station before hitting Salt Lake -- Carson's Creek station -- one short twelve hour ride from Zion and both stages and all eight people STOP FOR FOUR DAYS. (BTW, this stop isn't noticeable in the reading of Burton, you'll only see it if you follow his log and add up the days.) Now, why stay for four days at a station Burton describes as being wretched when you are only 12 hours from the relatived refined accommodations of that largest city between St. Jo. and Sacramento? I don't know, but the whole travel set-up feels staged and fake and weird to me.

Burton may have stayed at Carson's Creek for so long because it was run by Ephraim Hanks, one of the top dogs of the Mormon Danite secret society. The Danites were the de facto spy-scout organization used by Brigham Young in the Johnston war of 1857 and all throughout the 50's and 60's they served as a sort of Life Guards, Secret Police, and Hashishim for the Mormon Prophet. In other words, they were the Mormon KGB to Burton's MI6 so it is only natural that he should seek them out if he was on the mission I postulate. As to why everyone else in both stages would stop so close to home, my answer is, I don't think they did. I think Burton has fudged his intinerary to cover his tracks. He was up to something, but I don't yet know what it was.

Personally, I don't think that the phantom second stage may never have existed and although Lt. Dana existed and was assigned to Camp Floyd for about eight months before the whole she-bang rolled up its carpets after Ft. Sumter and went east again, I haven't been able to find him. My suspicion is that perhaps this Dana (not to be confused with Asst. Sec. of War Charles or Gen. Nappy Jackson Tecumseh Dana) went South, not North at the outbreak of hostilities and that he was actually Burton's escort/entre to things military on the trip.

Remember, the military was deeply split between Union and successionist sympathies at this time, with most of the officers being southerners who were weighing which side to shift their loyalties to. Dana's own commanding officer at Camp Floyd would be among the first to declare for the South and leave his post in Utah at the outbreak. If anybody can find anything about this Dana, I'd be most grateful.

On another note, I'd like to pass along some backstory on the Mormons for those of you who don't follow that part of Western history. While they started out under Joseph Smith as a sort of Yankee abolitionist sect in Ohio and NY, those leanings were pretty much gone by the time the group hit Missouri and were forced to try to get along with their slave owning neighbors. In an early, futile effort to do that, Joseph pulled back the hand of fellowship from blacks and declared them to be under the mark of Cain. The gambit didn't work, the Mormon's southern neighbors still didn't trust them and booted them out of the state to Illinois on a rail. They didn't fair much better in Illinois, when their northern neighbors proved equally intolerant of a) their polygamist practices and b) their massive unified voting bloc. When Joseph and Hyrum were assassinated, Brigham and the rest turned their backs on the US and looked towards the unsettled, unenfranchised West. They thought of British Saskatchewan, but were rebuffed by Canada as being too hot a potato to handle so they fixed their sights on unsettled Mexican Territory between the western frontier and California.

Utah became the place in 1847 and we can only imagine Brigham's disappointment when war broke out between Santa Ana and the US while he was en route and suddenly, the Mormons find their coveted territory back in arm's length of Uncle Sam again. They briefly tried to form their own independent nation, but the US would have none of that and so for the next ten years they tried to get along with the hated 'Americats'. When the lucrative Overland route first opened up, Brig made a play for the mail contract and assigned his best frontiersmen Porter Rockwell and Bill Hickman to superintend the route, which they did for nearly a year before the US yanked the contract again and the 1857 phony war broke out.

Mormons viewed the 1857 war as being an unprovoked invasion by an intractable and oppressive federal foe and their mindset was as rabidly successionist as any Carolina Cavalier in Charleston. They immediately launched a campaign of highly effective guerrilla strikes against the wagon and cattle trains that were sent to supply the invasion army and the end result was that by the time Johnston's 10th and 5th infantry got to Ft. Bridger, they were cut-off in mid-winter with no blankets and little food. Where the Mormons differed from the South was in their realization that they could not hope to beat the Union Army in the long run, so over the course of that long winter, they worked out a deal for peace that allowed the Army to enter the territory in exchange for amnesty for the Mormon combattants. They were defeated, but not beaten.

In the meantime, Mormon missionaries had flocked to the British Isles and converted tens of thousands of poor, working-class Cornish, Welch, and Southern Brits to the new faith and those British saints had flocked to their New Jerusalem in droves over the past decade. As a result Burton is widely recognized by his countrymen everywhere he goes in Utah and his travelogue is constantly peppered with notes about meeting yet another Brit everywhere he stops. (Although I must confess, most of the Brits he mentions are the young pretty female Brits.)

By 1860 there were so many British saints in Utah that Mormon the Mormon accent had begun to change and about Welsh-Cornish pronunciations for some words and today the Mormons are ethnically so Anglo-Scandanavian that Utah has become one of the least racially diverse states in the nation.

The long and short of the Mormon's political perigrination was that in the 30 years since the sects's foundation they had gone from Yankee abolitionist crackpots to Half-English secessionist crackpots. The minute the War broke out and the Army picked up stakes, the Mormons descended on the decaying carcass of Camp Floyd and picked it's bones clean, buying or carrying off everything that the soldiers didn't burn behind them. The Mormons celebrated the resulting federal void, but it would prove to be shortlived. The Army realized its hasty mistake and quickly ordered another army East from California who marched through Salt Lake and took up residence even closer to town at Camp Douglas. This time the Army didn't make the same mistake with its company commander. The Irish Unionist Colonel Patrick Connor was not about to defect South or take any guff from the Mormons


Subject

Richard Burton and the Mormons

Name

Mark Blanchard ([email protected])

Writen

6/2/01, 4:10 PM

Dear Lee and Chris,

I'm happy to see that we have several minds probing this issue. Perhaps we'll be able to get at some truth (or a reasonable facsimile thereof) if we keep at it. I'm going to focus on the Mormon aspect of the trip since it jives with my book (historical fiction of the Flashman type) and I'll make sure to update here regularly with what I find. Let me tell you some of the strange things I've noticed in the past week or so.

First, I should respond to why Burton didn't bother to chat with the St. Louis furtraders mentioned. He probably didn't think they had anything novel or unique to contribute to his mission, that's why. That's because the overland regions were no longer mysterious unexplored territories -- that narrow strip of land was a well-documented continental superhighway over which hundreds of thousands had passed and Burton was not out to explore or sightsee or indian fight. He was there to get to Salt Lake City as expeditiously as possible so he took the fastest, most direct route and didn't really pause much along the way. Except in very weird places.

Consider these interesting tidbits I've discovered. Burton leaves by direct stage out of St. Jo on Aug 7th with not one stage but in TWO coaches in highly unusual sort of coach for hire kind of an arrangement. He does not name the companions who travel in this second stage, but he does name Lt. James Dana and wife who go with him in the first stage. These two stages travel across the plains non-stop TOGETHER for the next five days. Then they start slowing down, again together, pausing every night to rest before continuing the next day. On this trip they pause at several forts, chat casually with the soldiers, but never once deviate from their trip to visit or hunt or try to scare up an indian fight. It's straight through all the way.

Then they get to their final station before hitting Salt Lake -- Carson's Creek station -- one short twelve hour ride from Zion and both stages and all eight people STOP FOR FOUR DAYS. (BTW, this stop isn't noticeable in the reading of Burton, you'll only see it if you follow his log and add up the days.) Now, why stay for four days at a station Burton describes as being wretched when you are only 12 hours from the relatived refined accommodations of that largest city between St. Jo. and Sacramento? I don't know, but the whole travel set-up feels staged and fake and weird to me.

Burton may have stayed at Carson's Creek for so long because it was run by Ephraim Hanks, one of the top dogs of the Mormon Danite secret society. The Danites were the de facto spy-scout organization used by Brigham Young in the Johnston war of 1857 and all throughout the 50's and 60's they served as a sort of Life Guards, Secret Police, and Hashishim for the Mormon Prophet. In other words, they were the Mormon KGB to Burton's MI6 so it is only natural that he should seek them out if he was on the mission I postulate. As to why everyone else in both stages would stop so close to home, my answer is, I don't think they did. I think Burton has fudged his intinerary to cover his tracks. He was up to something, but I don't yet know what it was.

Personally, I don't think that the phantom second stage may never have existed and although Lt. Dana existed and was assigned to Camp Floyd for about eight months before the whole she-bang rolled up its carpets after Ft. Sumter and went east again, I haven't been able to find him. My suspicion is that perhaps this Dana (not to be confused with Asst. Sec. of War Charles or Gen. Nappy Jackson Tecumseh Dana) went South, not North at the outbreak of hostilities and that he was actually Burton's escort/entre to things military on the trip.

Remember, the military was deeply split between Union and successionist sympathies at this time, with most of the officers being southerners who were weighing which side to shift their loyalties to. Dana's own commanding officer at Camp Floyd would be among the first to declare for the South and leave his post in Utah at the outbreak. If anybody can find anything about this Dana, I'd be most grateful.

On another note, I'd like to pass along some backstory on the Mormons for those of you who don't follow that part of Western history. While they started out under Joseph Smith as a sort of Yankee abolitionist sect in Ohio and NY, those leanings were pretty much gone by the time the group hit Missouri and were forced to try to get along with their slave owning neighbors. In an early, futile effort to do that, Joseph pulled back the hand of fellowship from blacks and declared them to be under the mark of Cain. The gambit didn't work, the Mormon's southern neighbors still didn't trust them and booted them out of the state to Illinois on a rail. They didn't fair much better in Illinois, when their northern neighbors proved equally intolerant of a) their polygamist practices and b) their massive unified voting bloc. When Joseph and Hyrum were assassinated, Brigham and the rest turned their backs on the US and looked towards the unsettled, unenfranchised West. They thought of British Saskatchewan, but were rebuffed by Canada as being too hot a potato to handle so they fixed their sights on unsettled Mexican Territory between the western frontier and California.

Utah became the place in 1847 and we can only imagine Brigham's disappointment when war broke out between Santa Ana and the US while he was en route and suddenly, the Mormons find their coveted territory back in arm's length of Uncle Sam again. They briefly tried to form their own independent nation, but the US would have none of that and so for the next ten years they tried to get along with the hated 'Americats'. When the lucrative Overland route first opened up, Brig made a play for the mail contract and assigned his best frontiersmen Porter Rockwell and Bill Hickman to superintend the route, which they did for nearly a year before the US yanked the contract again and the 1857 phony war broke out.

Mormons viewed the 1857 war as being an unprovoked invasion by an intractable and oppressive federal foe and their mindset was as rabidly successionist as any Carolina Cavalier in Charleston. They immediately launched a campaign of highly effective guerrilla strikes against the wagon and cattle trains that were sent to supply the invasion army and the end result was that by the time Johnston's 10th and 5th infantry got to Ft. Bridger, they were cut-off in mid-winter with no blankets and little food. Where the Mormons differed from the South was in their realization that they could not hope to beat the Union Army in the long run, so over the course of that long winter, they worked out a deal for peace that allowed the Army to enter the territory in exchange for amnesty for the Mormon combattants. They were defeated, but not beaten.

In the meantime, Mormon missionaries had flocked to the British Isles and converted tens of thousands of poor, working-class Cornish, Welch, and Southern Brits to the new faith and those British saints had flocked to their New Jerusalem in droves over the past decade. As a result Burton is widely recognized by his countrymen everywhere he goes in Utah and his travelogue is constantly peppered with notes about meeting yet another Brit everywhere he stops. (Although I must confess, most of the Brits he mentions are the young pretty female Brits.)

By 1860 there were so many British saints in Utah that Mormon the Mormon accent had begun to change and about Welsh-Cornish pronunciations for some words and today the Mormons are ethnically so Anglo-Scandanavian that Utah has become one of the least racially diverse states in the nation.

The long and short of the Mormon's political perigrination was that in the 30 years since the sects's foundation they had gone from Yankee abolitionist crackpots to Half-English secessionist crackpots. The minute the War broke out and the Army picked up stakes, the Mormons descended on the decaying carcass of Camp Floyd and picked it's bones clean, buying or carrying off everything that the soldiers didn't burn behind them. The Mormons celebrated the resulting federal void, but it would prove to be shortlived. The Army realized its hasty mistake and quickly ordered another army East from California who marched through Salt Lake and took up residence even closer to town at Camp Douglas. This time the Army didn't make the same mistake with its company commander. The Irish Unionist Colonel Patrick Connor was not about to defect South or take any guff from the Mormons.

And by the way, guess which two stops on his itinerary figure most prominently in the last part of Burton's trip? You guessed it, his visit to Camp Floyd and his pow-wow with Porter Rockwell, another one of the Mormon KGB chieftains. That's what I've got now, more later.

Mark


Subject

Carson's Creek

Name

Christopher Dickey ([email protected])

Writen

6/2/01, 4:14 PM

The bit about Carson's Creek Station and Ephraim Hanks is news to me -- and abscolutely fascinating.


Post a new message

Name

Email

Subject

Message

Optional Link URL

(Link Title)

This message is part of the message board for Sir Richard F. Burton on the Web, a web guide and directory to the African explorer, travel writer and translator of the Arabian Nights and the Kama Sutra.