|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Topic: Duel with Spekes? Started by Jeremy Blaustein on 10/10/00, 10:04 AM Subject
Duel with Spekes? Name
Jeremy Blaustein ([email protected]) Writen 10/10/00, 10:04 AM I'm currently reading the biography "A Rage to Live". Considering not only Spekes treachery but also his outright insults and defamation of Burton's character (or perhaps they weren't outright but were only in private correspondences), I wonder why did Burton not challenge him to a duel? I know they were illegal at the time, but it certainly seems that RB must have at least been tempted to run him through. Like to hear any opinions. Subject
NonDuel with Speke Name
leland Purvis ([email protected]) Writen 11/17/00, 8:52 PM Jeremy, Subject
duel or no duel Name
Heather Llewellyn ([email protected]) Writen 11/28/00, 12:47 AM I would tend to agree with both of you, but if his biographies are anything to go by, than one would be lead to believe that the day that Speke died, was the time that Burton was going to duel him, although not with weapons, but with words, which with this particular character, could be just as deadly. Most of the biographies I have read, state that they were going to "discuss" their different beliefs on where the Nile started at that Royal Geographical Society conference (for lack of a better word) that they were both attending, which had Speke not left and ended killing himself accidentally, would have probably been quite a thing to witness. Subject
Duel with Speke Name
roark mitzell ([email protected]) Writen 5/14/02, 10:19 AM I heartily agree with Leland Purvis on the duel issue. Whether with sword or pistol, Speke would have been totally outclassed by Burton. It seems to me, as well, that those who really got to know Burton found a much more humane and gentle man than the creature who "broke every sin in the decalogue"%3B the public creature which Burton helped create, foster, and perpetuate. If Burton was enraged and hurt by Speke's abominable actions upon his return to Britain, I don't think Burton would have gained any "satisfaction" from a physical duel with Speke. I think he was very much aware of his superiority with weapons, and Burton was not a murderer. As Mr. purvis stated, as well, duelling- by this decade in the Victorian era, was very much a "Continental" tradition, and was frowned upon in Britain. The pistol had very much superceded the sword at this point, but use of either in settling disputes of honor were looked down unpon by British gentlemen. And, although Burton was a very cosmopolitan creaure, religiously, politically, linguistically... In all the ways, in fact, that make Burton the man he was,I cannot help but feel that at the heart of Burton's complex psyche, he did indeed consider himself English- by birthright even if he spent so many years of his childhood elsewhere. I beleive Fawn Brody calls Burton a Renaissance man due to his many talents and interests, and suggests that he was born in the wrong age, and would have thrived in the Renaissance. Actually, due to his religious views, he would have been very much a pariah in the 16th century, and would have been considered a heretic at least, if not worse. In truth, due to the extremes of Burton's character, he would have been an outcast, a rogue, in any era. He would have placed himself beyond the pale of any culture into which he had been born. By the same token, one cannot read his beautiful and moving toast to Queen Victorian upon the celebration of her Jubilee, and not sense the incredible devotion and pride he felt concerning Her Majesty, and the Empire. The man groused for years over the idiocy displayed by English politicians or the narrow views and interests of the general population... His toast however reveals a very different, sincere, heartfelt emotion. Burton was as British as his Continental upbringing allowed. He was as British as his psyche would allow. He was as British as his religious views would allow. Take all his ravings and writings about social, political, and religous mediocrity in Britain and compare it to his words concerning Victoria and the Empire in the twilight of his life and I don't think anyone could refute that he felt himself to be an Englishman. He was as British as his experiential frame of reference would allow, and therefore, I don't think he would entertain the idea of challenging Speke to a physical duel, due to his ethics or his own unique stance- nevermind his writings as a used, abused, idealistic, embittered ex-patriot- as an Englishman.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
This message is part of the message board for Sir Richard F. Burton on the Web, a web guide and directory to the African explorer, travel writer and translator of the Arabian Nights and the Kama Sutra. |