Sir Richard F. Burton on the Web: Message Board

Return to Topics
|
Post a reply/new message
|
Return to Web Page

Post a reply/new message

Topic: Homosexual?

Started by Fred Carney on 11/13/00, 9:34 PM


Subject

Homosexual?

Name

Fred Carney

Writen

11/13/00, 9:34 PM

Was Burton a homosexual?


Subject

Burton and Homosexuality

Name

J. Patterson

Writen

11/14/00, 3:37 AM


I have pondered this question myself. I do not think Burton was a homosexual, though I am not discounting the fact that he had homosexual interactions, particularly while researching the infamous brothel report that followed him through much of his civil career.

Of course, it may depend on how one defines homosexuality. If it is defines as a lifestyle or prefered sexula preference, then Burton was not likely a homosexual. On the other hand, if one considers homosexuality to be any same sex encounter, then it is possible that Burton could be one. Based on my readings I tend to support the former.

Cheers,


Subject

Burton and homosexuality

Name

Patricio Canahuate

Writen

11/20/00, 4:21 PM

I agree entirely with you. And it does make sense that he%B4d have homosexual and any other kind of encounters in the name of learning what makes us "tick" as human beings. As human entities, the same amount of chromosomes come from the father (male) as well as the mother (female), which would support a theory for liking members of our own sex at some point or another, since "likes" or "opposites" are both covered by our genetic make up. Burton was definitely always ahead of his (and our) time! It is indeed a pity that a copy of his famous report hasn%B4t yet been found (if it exists).


Subject

Who cares?

Name

Buckwheat (not offered)

Writen

2/4/01, 11:41 PM

The fact that Burton investigated and apparently documented the presence of English officers in male brothels does not mean he had homosexual encounters of his own, any more than a detective working a vice unit would commit the crimes he was investigating in order to document them. That assumption is patently silly and betrays a total lack of knowledge of investigative procedure. What does it really matter what Burton's inclinations were, really, anyway? Does it detract from his accomplishments? Does it add to them? Or, are some, who think homosexuality is some predictor of genius, trying to enlist his name into the ever-enlarging cabal of alleged "homosexuals" (Socrates, Alexander the Great to name two) that greatly influenced the modern world? Everything I have read on the man indicates quite the opposite, and don't you think if any of his enemies, and he had many, many, many! had the slightest evidence of homosexual behavior on his part, that it would have used to smear him? Don't forget this was the government that sent Oscar Wilde to Reading Gaol for merely refusing to deny he loved another man!!! The fact is, Burton loved women, and made no secret of his enjoyment of the company of female prostitutes. Presumably, he was making love with them.


Subject

Have you seen the film "Zero Patience"?

Name

Dickon Edwards ([email protected])

Writen

5/12/01, 10:12 AM

Link

Zero Patience

"Zero Patience" is a recent independent Canadian film I can recommend for the curious. It's a surreal musical about AIDS, along the lines of "The Rocky Horror Picture Show". Burton is one of the main characters, depicted as living among us today. And yes, he gets to "research" homosexuality...

It's available on video. Link attached.


Subject

uh, apparently you care quite a bit

Name

jon-jon ([email protected])

Writen

4/17/02, 2:23 PM

Methinks you protest too much "Buckwheat." Anyway I don't know who tried to tell you that homosexuality is the precursor of genius, although not only Socrates and Alexander the Great, but Caesar, Martial, Catallus, Hadrian, Napoleon, Newton, Goethe, Shakespeare, Emerson, Wilde, Whitman, etc ad nauseum might be added to the list of great men who dared inquire into that most proscribed and persecuted of fornications. Certain of the ideas of Plato form the cornerstone of the mind of practically everyone living today%3B it may at least be said that his notorious homosexuality did not detract from his genius.

I'm unconcerned with positively asserting any sort of causal connection - God forbid! But this insinuation that the issue is completely unimportant and even embarrassing to serious scholarship is, at the very least, bigoted. Burton himself evidently thought it important enough. I think it's a little ridiculous to pretend that you can deduce a man's potential for homosexuality from his lifestyle, his demeanor, even his professed (and undoubtedly genuine) love of women. Yes, "presumably he was making love" with those female prostitutes. I would suggest that it's only your own bias that leads you to "presume" that his interest in the male brothels was entirely "scientific."

The man had some nerve, and the audacity he showed in publishing those nasty footnotes to the "Thousand Nights and One Night" in arch-prudish Victorian England was no less than that evinced in his undercover penetration of the mysterious sects of Islam.

The real identifying trait of all those great men listed is that they cared not a whit for the vulgar opinions of men beneath them.


Post a new message

Name

Email

Subject

Message

Optional Link URL

(Link Title)

This message is part of the message board for Sir Richard F. Burton on the Web, a web guide and directory to the African explorer, travel writer and translator of the Arabian Nights and the Kama Sutra.