The Ancient Library
 

Scanned text contains errors.

108 VARIETIES OF OLIGARCHY. [CH. IV. -

form.' He is careful to lay stress on the superiority of the moderate forms of either oligarchy or democracy to the extreme forms; and his lesson was needed, for there was a strong tendency in Greece to intensify the ruling characteristics of the constitutions'. The extreme oli-garchy was almost a tyranny, the most moderate form . was but little removed from a moderate democracy, and Aristotle describes it in almost the same terms8.

The first principle applied to the subdivision of oli­garchies is connected with the conditions qualifying for citizenship. A second test is afforded by the method of admitting those who attained the qualification to the active exercise of citizen rights. Political privilege might be offered freely to all who fulfilled certain conditions; it might be extended to the excluded only at the discre­tion of the ruling body; or the ranks of the privileged, once fixed, might be closed against all without the pale. This distinction is important. In sentiment and in conduct there must have been the greatest difference between governments constantly recruited by fresh blood and close corporations which jealously guarded their privileges against the rest. Lastly, Aristotle has another means of distinction. Oligarchies are either ruled ac­cording to law or they are controlled by the caprice of individuals, a criterion which also enters into his classifi­cation of constitutions in general.

7 On the intensification of constitutions see Ar. Pol. vii 5 1319 b 32. The champions of oligarchy and democracy were not content with the moderate forms; they strove to increase their worst characteristics. Of. Thuc. t 81 (the Spartans) t& (v "Zmvwvi it 6\lyovs fia\\ov Ka.Tt<mjyaj>.

8 Of. Pol. vi 6 1292 b 25—33 with ib. 1293 a 12—20. If neither passage is corrupt, the repetition of the same phrases in both definitions is strange.

Pages
About | Contents | Index

107

108

109
page  
Search this site
Google


isidore-of-seville.com
WWW