Scanned text contains errors.
§ 6] ARISTOCRACY. 29
under state control was maintained. This training, carried out in accordance with traditional rules26 and directed to inculcate habits of patriotism and obedience and to fit the citizen for the duties of war, was supposed to be productive of 'political virtue27.' Governments, therefore, based on such a system of training were properly classified as aristocracies, and their characteristic features did in fact supply the terms of a definition of aristocracy both to Xenophon and to Aristotle29.
This brief survey suffices to show that the Greek conception of aristocracy does permit us to apply formal principles of classification; that constitutions based on birth or training might both be included among the •governments of virtue,' and inasmuch as the system of training was usually maintained only within a privileged class the Greek definition of aristocracy, in its application
as Thera) and some of the smaller Dorian states (such as Epidaurus) may have practised it.
* The training was based upon 'ordinances' (v6iiu.ua.), which I take to denote traditional (and probably unwritten) laws. Cf. Eth. x 9 1179 34 al pkv ya,p KOivaL frtfifXeiat SfjXov sti Sta vbfiwv ytvovrai. On vSfjUfia cf. the passages quoted in note 28, and the descriptions of Sparta quoted below § 32.
v Omitting the particular evidence of Sparta (on which see § 32 below), Ar. Pol. vi 7 1293 b 12 talks of states that make kou-tj tri/iAem i.prnjs. Cf. iii 12 1283 a 25 on the association of ratSela and dpen}. Mr Hicks in his note says that Aristotle uses the words interchangeably.
18 Xen. Mem, iv 6 12. In an aristocracy offices are appointed « t<m to vkiu.ua. iTtrcXotWup. (These are the rules of training.) Ar. Rhet. i 8 1365 b 34 adopts and enlarges this definition. apia-TOKparia iv g ot Kara, TatSctav (JtoW/joiTcu ris dpx^s)- ntStlaf Si \£yo> rt/v faro tov viifiav ot ya,p Ifi/utuviiKOTes et> tois no/u/utts iv r-y dptoroK/xtrl? Apxovatr. Si roi/rous <txjJ.vea9<u iplffrovs. Cf. Pol. vi 15 1299 b 25 oi rorot-t are described as the governing class in an aristocracy. We may compare the importance attached to education in the ideal states of both