5843 through 5853 Germantown Avenue has been reconfigured over time into a variety of different sites:

• 5843-45-47. Turnpike Toll House and Potter Row. Demolished.
• 5843. 1982 Register: Samuel Badder store, 1922, C. Cummiskey, architect, Colonial Revival style. --- Contributing.
• 5845. 1982 Register: Max Louis Store and Apartment, 1926, Lippincott & Schaeffer, architects, Moderne style. --- Contributing.
• 5847-51. 1982 Register: "Commercial building c. 1940, one story. --- Intrusion."
• 5849-51-53. First Presbyterian Church/YMCA. 1812 building demolished in 1892. 1892 building also demolished.