- from the Times History of the War volume 18
- The Raid on Zeebrugge
The New Spirit in the British Navy and Its Significance
![]()
a view on the aftermath of the raid as seen by German newsmagazines
The waters opposite the Flanders shore are shallow, with shifting sand-banks and many shoals. Heavy warships of large draught are therefore unable to approach, and the channels both to Zeebrugge and Ostend are narrow and tortuous, making entrance far from easy even for small craft, and until dredging operations had been carried out the submarines based on these ports were light vessels sent overland in sections to be put together at Antwerp and then transported by canal to the sea. From Bruges there are two canals to the coast, one to Ostend and the other to Zeebruggethe latter, the much wider and deeper straight-cut, intended for the purpose of carrying sea-borne traffic. These canals are connected by locks with the artificial harbours constructed at each port. That at Zeebrugge is partly enclosed by a long stone breakwater joined to the land by a railway viaduct, and between the ports the coast is formed by a chain of sand-dunes, which provided cover for the heavy batteries erected behind them.
The enemy quickly got to work at the two ports, and especially at Zeebrugge, where military store-houses and workshops were constructed, and preparations of many kinds made for the conversion of the harbours into defended positions for submarine and destroyer operations. The docks and shipbuilding yards at Bruges were largely extended, and aerodromes erected from which raids could be made upon this country. During 1915, offensive measures were taken against the two seaports by flotillas of British monitors and other craft, and their headquarters at Bruges was bomb d by the Naval Air Service stationed at Dunkirk. In that year the enemy torpedo-craft, and especially the minelayers and other submarines, constituted a distinct menace to the traffic passing through the Straits of Dover. The Harwich and Dover Patrols, however, did excellent work, and were most vigilant in counteracting the threat of the enemy, while the aircraft inflicted a considerable amount of damage upon the works of military importance. In the course of the following year the enemy showed much greater activity, both in the provision of batteries on the coast and in the forays made by their submarines and destroyers upon the trade on the English coast. The systematic dredging of the channels permitted the use of much more powerful destroyers and larger submarines. Mining was carried out to a very wide extent, making still more difficult the approach to the beach, and guns of large calibre and long range were mounted in the fortifications. The digue at Ostend became a fortress, and was described as a town of dug-outs, of concrete works, of gun- platforms, and of blockhouses. The Tirpitz battery near the same place was furnished with very heavy guns capable of a range of over 30,000 yards, and these guns were protected by cupolas of thick armour. Similarly, at Zeebrugge, the coast bristled with ordnance in large numbers of heavy calibre up to 15-inch. It was said that between 120 and 150 heavy pieces of artillery were mounted among the dunes at the back of the beach. At the end of the breakwater or Mole at Zeebrugge, where there was a lighthouse with searchlight and range-finder, a battery of powerful guns, strongly protected, was placed, and on the breakwater itself, in addition to the railway terminus, there was a seaplane station, barracks for personnel, and sheds for stores and other material, with machine-gun positions for their defence. Unfortunately, while the Germans were making progress with their defensive and offensive preparations, our measures of interference with their activity were not on the same scale, nor were they pushed with the energy which had formerly been so marked. Towards the end of 1916 the raids and forays of the enemy craft working from the Belgian bases had become so frequent and were characterized by such audacity and determination as to attract general attention in England, and cause something like a feeling of apprehension in the south-eastern counties. The raids upon the Kentish coast and the attempts to pass the Dover Straits made at this time, and how they became considerably diminished after the extremely gallant and successful action in which the flotilla leaders Broke and Swift distinguished themselves, have been described in previous chapters.
It was many times urged upon the authorities that the only satisfactory method of dealing with the menace from the Flanders ports would be to destroy the ports and render them useless as lairs for the enemy craft. The tons of high explosive dropped from the air and the intermittent bombardment at long intervals of the fortifications, while these resulted in extensive damage, were insufficient and inadequate by themselves. Something on a larger scale and of a more permanent character in the way of destruction was required to be really effective. Proposals for blocking the canals had been made as early as the first months of the war, but nothing came of them. When Sir Edward Carson and Lord Jellicoe had succeeded Mr. Balfour and Sir Henry Jackson at the Admiralty in the early part of 1917 a definite plan of action for this purpose was seriously considered.
It was not until November, 1917, that the project materialized in the Plans Division of the Admiralty, at the head of which was a young flag officer named Roger Keyes. In this division a great scheme, having for its purpose the blocking of Zeebrugge, of the ship canal, and a similar undertaking at Ostend, was prepared and elaborated, and when it had obtained official sanction and encouragement, the talented and energetic Admiral under whose direction it had been drawn up was sent down to Dover to relieve Sir Reginald Bacon in command of the patrol for the purpose of putting it into execution. The great adventure took place in the early morning of April 23, St. George's Day.
The plan as arranged was to use certain obsolete vessels filled with concrete for sealing up the two harbours, while, at the same time and with the object of diverting attention from these block-ships, an attack was made on the battery and other establishments on the Mole at Zeebrugge and the railway viaduct connecting the breakwater with the shore blown up. It was essential to success that the enterprise should be a complete surprise and that both the blocking ships and the party attacking the Mole should reach their objectives before the heavier batteries of the enemy could put them out of action. As the storming of the Mole was intended to distract the attention of the defenders, this operation was timed to begin before the blocking-ships appeared, and thus to take the first brunt of whatever artillery fire the enemy could bring to bear. In order to screen the movements of the attacking vessels, an artificial fog or smoke mist, which had already been found to work satisfactorily, was to be made by the small craft which were to accompany the larger vessels and take part in reselling their crews. Also, as a further diversion, while these vessels were making their approach to the ports, a force of monitors and aerial bombing machines was to set up a bombardment of the shore batteries and other positions of military importance in the vicinity of the two ports.
As already stated, the conduct of the whole business was in the hands of Vice- Admiral Keyes. Six old cruisers selected for the purpose were specially prepared for the expedition.
The Vindictive was to carry out the attack upon the Mole and had been supplied on the side which would be nearer the breakwater with a high false deck, fitted with brows or gangways by which the storming and demolition parties she carried were to land. Accompanying her were two old Mersey ferry-boats, the Iris and Daffodil, also carrying part of the landing force, and the Daffodil, it was also arranged, was to push the Vindictive against the breakwater if the grappling-irons with which) she was fitted failed to effect their purpose. The Vindictive was commanded by Acting-Captain A. F. B. Carpenter, R.N., the Iris by Commander Valentine Gibbs, R.N., and the Daffodil by Lieutenant H. G. Campbell, R.N. The commands of the various landing parties were distributed as follows: The Naval brigade under Acting-Captain H. C. Halahan, D.S.O., R.N., and the Royal Marines under Lieutenant-Colonel B. N. Elliot, D.S.O., R.M.L.I., with Lieutenant-Commander A. L. Harrison, R.N., and Lieutenant C. C. Dickinson, R.N., in charge of the storming and demolition bodies respectively. Two submarines were detailed to blow up the viaduct; one of these was commanded by Lieutenant A. C Newbold, R.N., and the other by Lieutenant R. D. Sandford, R.N., and attached to these submarines was a picket-boat commanded by Lieutenant- Commander F. H, Sandford, D.S.O., R.N.
The vessels selected for blocking were, like the Vindictive, ancient and obsolete cruisers, which before the war had been fitted out as minelayers. For their present purpose they had been stripped of everything except their engines and armament, and in addition to the concrete carried explosives to blow their hulls to pieces when they grounded. Those to be used at Zeebrugge were the Thetis, Commander R. S. Sneyd, D.S.O.,R.N., Intrepid, Lieutenant S. S. Bonham Carter, R.N., and Iphigenia, Lieutenant E. W. Billyard-Leake, R.N., who at the last moment replaced Lieutenant I. B. Franks, R.N., who had to go to hospital for an operation. For the Ostend undertaking the ships chosen were the Brilliant, Commander A. E. Godsal, R.N., and Sirius, Lieutenant-Commander H. N. M. Hardy, D.S.O., R.N. A flotilla of motor vessels under the command of Captain Ralph Collins, R.N., and Commander Hamilton Benn, M.P., R.N.V.R., with another of coastal motor-boats under Lieutenant Wel-man, R.N., were charged with the duty of assisting the block-ships in finding their objectives, making the smoke screens, and aiding the crews of the sunken vessels to make their escape.
Three destroyers were -also assigned duties in the attack, the North Star, Lieutenant- Commander K. C. Helyar, the Phoebe, Lieutenant-Commander H. E. Gore-Langton, R.N., and the Warwick. In the last-named Vice-Admiral Roger Keyes flew his flag, and from her he directed the whole operation. The admiral's final signal as the Vindictive advanced to the attack was a reminder of the day, "St. George for England!" and the reply made by Captain Carpenter was, " May we give the Dragon's tail a damned good twist! "
Altogether between 70 and 80 ships and boats took part in the affair; but, in addition, the naval force at Harwich, under Rear-Admiral Sir Reginald Tyrwhitt, D.S.O., and the Grand Fleet in the North Sea, were on the alert to prevent any attempt from the German Bight to interfere with the proceedings. A small French contingent from Dunkirk also participated.
The following graphic account of the daring exploit was given by Captain Carpenter:
"Once it had been decided to make an attack on the Mole we had to have a large number of men to carry it out, and to obtain suitable ships. So the Grand Fleet, the main naval depots, and the various Commands, such as Dover, were asked to lend a certain number of the most suitable men they had. These men were given to understand that they were going on a hazardous enterprise, so far as I know, and therefore one can say that they volunteered for it, although they were not actually told at the time what they were going to do. However, before the operation actually took place every man had to be informed quite clearly what was expected of him, because one fully realized that every officer might be knocked out and the men would be entirely on their own. Then the men undoubtedly had a chance of saying that they did not want to go, perhaps for family reasons; but, so far as I know, there was not a single case of a man asking to be left behind. To my knowledge, in fact, in one ship (the Intrepid), where orders had been given that certain men were to be left behind, those men in almost a mutinous spirit came up before the captain and said they absolutely refused to leave the ship. As it happened, in this particular case, owing to a slight hitch, the extra crew of this ship were not taken off. The whole of the men went into Zeebrugge Canal in the block ship, and the whole of them were saved and brought back.
"The nature of the operation was such that it required the use of a very large number of small craft, and the trip across the sea being rather over a hundred miles each way made it necessary that the weather should be fine. At the same time the wind had to be on-shore, so that we could use our smoke screens effectively. At the same time, too, the operation had to be carried out at high water, so as to allow the block ships to get in. Again, owing to the presence of a large number of German guns on the Belgian coast, it was necessary to carry out the operation at night, and it was fully realized that if it were carried out in the latter part of the nightthat is to say, by the morning twilightthere was practically no chance of any ship getting away in the early morning when they could be seen from the shore. It was, therefore, a rather complicated combination of conditions that we required, and during the period that we were waiting for a suitable day the disappointments were very great. Before the operation took place we had all gone over to within a few miles of our objectives and had to turn back owing to impossible weather conditions suddenly arising, and it was with very anxious hearts that we waited for suitable weather conditions to occur, realizing that every day we waited made a greater chance for the news of the impending operation to leak out and get across to Germany and for preparations to be made over there to defeat the operation at the outset. The chances of the vicinities of Zeebrugge and Ostend being heavily mined were considerable, and the risk of this had to be taken.
"At last the opportunity we had waited for so long arose, and everybody started off in the highest spirits and with no other thoughts than to make the very greatest success of the operation that we could possibly do. Fate was very kind to us on the whole, and everything went well, almost as per schedule. The various phases of the operation depended on accurate timing of the work of the various units. The smoke screen craft and the fast motor-boats at given intervals rushed on ahead at full speed, laid their smoke screens, attacked enemy vessels with torpedoes, and generally cleared the way for the main force, in addition to hiding the approach of the latter from the shore batteries. Meanwhile, a heavy bombardment was being carried out by our monitors, and the sound of their firing as we approached was one of the most heartening things that I can remember. On arriving at a certain point some considerable distance from shore the forces parted, some going to Zeebrugge and some to Ostend, the idea being the forces should arrive at the two places simultaneously, so that communication from one place to the other could not be used as a warning in either case. Precisely at midnight the main force arrived at Zeebrugge and two of the block ships arrived at Ostend.
"At midnight we steamed through a very thick smoke-screen. German star shells were lighting up the whole place almost like daylight, and one had an extraordinary naked feeling when one saw how exposed we were although it was in the middle of the night. On emerging from the smoke-screen the end of the Mole, where the lighthouse is, was seen close ahead, distant about 400 yards. The ship was turned immediately to go alongside and increased to full speed so as to get there as fast as possible. We had decided not to open fire from the ship until they opened fire on us, so that we might remain unobserved to the last possible moment. A battery of five or six guns on the Mole began firing at us almost immediately from a range of about 300 yards, and every gun on the Vindictive that could bear fired at them as hard as it could.
"In less than five minutes the ship was alongside the Mole, and efforts were made to grapple the Mole so as to keep the ship in place. The Daffodil, which was keeping close astern, came up, and in the most gallant manner placed her bow against the Vindictive and pushed the Vindictive sideways until she was close alongside the Mole. There was a very heavy swell against the Mole. The ships were rolling about, and this made the work of securing to the Mole exceedingly difficult.
"When the brows were run out from the Vindictive the men at once climbed out along them. It was an extremely perilous task, in view of the fact that the end of the brows at one moment were from 8 ft. to 10 ft. above the wall and the next moment were crashing on the wall as the ship rolled. The way in which the men got over those brows was almost superhuman. I expected every moment to see them falling off between the Mole and the shipat least a 30 ft. dropand being crushed by the ship against the wall. Btit not a man fell; their agility was wonderful. It was not a case of seamen running barefoot along the deck of a rolling ship; the men were carrying heavy accoutrements, bombs, Lewis guns, and other articles, and their path lay along a narrow and extremely unsteady plank. They never hesitated. They went along the brows and on to the Mole with the utmost possible speed. Within a few minutes three to four hundred had been landed, and under cover of a barrage put down on the Mole by Stokes guns and howitzer fire from the ship they fought their way along.
"Comparatively few of the German guns were able to hit the hull of the ship, as it was behind the protection of the wall. Safety, in fact, depended on how near you could get to the enemy guns instead of how far away. While the hull was guarded the upper works of the shipthe funnels, masts, ventilators, and bridgewere showing above the wall, and on these a large number of German guns appeared to be concentrated. Many of our casualties were caused by splinters coming down from the upper works. If it had not been for the Daffodil continuing to push the ship in towards the wall throughout the operation none of the men who went on the Mole would ever have got back again.
"About 25 minutes after the Vindictive got alongside, the block ships were seen rounding the lighthouse, and heading for the canal entrance. It was then realized on board the Iris, Daffodil, and Vindictive that their work had been accomplished. A quarter of an hour after the Vindictive took her position, and just before the blockers arrived, a tremendous explosion was seen at the shore end of the Mole. We then knew that our submarine had managed to get herself in between the piles of the viaduct connecting the Mole with the shore and had blown herself up. She carried several tons of high explosive, and the effect of her action was effectually to cut off the Mole from the land. Before the explosion the crew of the submarine, which comprised some half-dozen officers and men, got away in a very small motor-skiff, which lost its propeller and had to be pulled with paddles against a heavy tide and under machine-gun fire from a range which could be reckoned only in feet. Most of the crew were wounded, but the tiny boat was picked up by a steam pinnace. "It is possible that the Germans who saw the submarine coming in under the play of their searchlights thought that her object was to attack the vessels within the Mole, and that she thought it feasible to get through the viaduct to do this. Their neglect to stop the submarine as she approached could only be put down to the fact that they knew she could not get through owing to the large amount of interlacing between the piles, and that they really believed they were catching her. A large number of Germans were actually on the viaduct a few feet above the submarine, and were firing at her with machine-guns. I think it can safely be said that every one of those Germans went up with the viaduct. The cheer raised by my men in the Vindictive when they saw the terrific explosion was one of the finest things I ever heard. Many of the men were severely woundedsome had three and even four woundsbut they had no thought except for the success of the operation.
"The block ships came under very heavy fire immediately they rounded the end of the Mole. Most Of the fire, it appears, was concentrated on the leading ship, the Thetis. She ran ashore off the entrance to the canal on the edge of the channel, and was sunk as approximately as possible across the channel itself, thus forming an obstruction to the passage of the German vessels. Before going down she gave a signal to the other two block ships, which were following close behind, to inform them which side of her to pass in order to get to the canal entrance. This cooperation between the three block ships, carried out under extremely heavy fire, was one of the finest things of the operation. The second and third ships, the Intrepid and Iphigenia, both went straight through the canal entrance until they actually reached a point some two to three hundred yards inside the shore lines, and behind some of the German batteries. It really seems very wonderful. How the crews of the two ships ever got away is almost beyond imagination.
"The situation rather more than an hour after the Vindictive got alongside was this: The block ships had passed in, had come to the end of their run, and had done their work. The viaduct was blown up and the Mole had been stormed. Nothing but a useless sacrifice of life could have followed if the three boarding vessels had remained by the Mole any longer. The signal to withdraw was therefore given, and the ships got away under cover of their smoke-screens as quickly as they could. They went at full speed and were followed all the way along their course by salvos from the German guns. Shells seemed to fall all round the ships without actually hitting them. The gunners apparently had our speed but not our range, and with remarkable regularity the salvos plopped into the sea behind us. In a short time the ships were clear of imminent danger owing to the large amount of smoke which they had left behind them."
When the Vindictive ran alongside the Mole the landing parties were ready to swarm across the brows, but the hail of shrapnel and machine-gun fire took heavy toll of the stormers. Lieutenant-Colonel B. N. Elliot, D.S.O., R.M.L.I., Major A. A. Cordner, of the Marines, and Captain H. C. Halahan, D.S.O., R.N., were killed in the ship almost immediately. Lieutenant C. E. V. Hawkings, R.N., and Lieutenant-Commander G. N. Bradford, R.N., who carried the grappling anchors ashore from the Iris, were also killed. Biit led by Lieutenant-Commanders A. L. Harrison and B. F. Adams, R.N., and Lieutenants C. C. Dickinson and E. L. Berthon, D.S.C., R.N., and Major B. G. Weller, D.S.C., Captain E. Bamford,Lieutenants C. R. W. Lamplough and G. Underhill, of the Royal Marines, the bluejackets and marines rushed across the gangways with undaunted gallantry and fought their way splendidly into the German defences. In a rush for a machine-gun battery Lieutenant-Commandei A. L. Harrison, R.JSL, was killed, and at the lighthouse Lieutenant-Colonel F. A. Brock, R.A.F. (Wing- Commander, R.N.), lost his life. This talented officer was the inventor of the smokescreen, which, as Sir Eric Geddes admitted, alone made the undertaking possible. Exposed to terrific fire, there was great loss of life in the Iris, Commander V. F. Gibbs, R.N., in command of the vessel, and her navigator, Lieutenant G. Spencer, D.S.C., R.N.R., both died of their wounds. Major C. E. C. Eagles, D.S.O., and Lieutenant S. H. E. Inskip, of the Royal Marines, were also killed, and many others, but the work was carried out in perfect order and many deeds of heroism were performed in its execution. The crew of the Thetis after she blew up were rescued by a motor launch under the command of Lieutenant H. A. Littleton, R.N. V.R., that of the Intrepid by another motor launch under Lieutenant P. T. Dean, R.N.V.R., and that of the Iphigenia by the same motor launch, the survivors being eventually transferred to a destroyer. The only material loss of any importance was the North Star, destroyer, sunk by gunfire, most of the crew being picked up by the Phcebe under cover of a smoke-screen. At Ostend the operations were conducted by Commodore Hubert Lynes, R.N., and there a change of wind brought about a less satisfactory result than was achieved at Zeebrugge. The flares lit by motor launches became visible to the enemy and were extinguished by gun fire. As these flares were intended to show the ends of the wooden piers leading to the harbour, their absence threw the blocking ships out of their course and they were run aground and blown up outside the entrance. The crews of the ships were rescued as fearlessly as were those at Zeebrugge, by motor launches commanded by Lieutenants K. R. Hoare, D.S.C., R.N.V.R., and R. Bourke, R.N.V.R. The total casualties suffered in the dual enterprise amounted to 588 officers and men. Of these there were 21 officers killed and missing and 29 wounded, and 184 other ratings killed and missing and 354 wounded.
The British Navy was not a force to leave its work unfinished, and a further expedition was planned to complete the job at Ostend. The Vindictive was still seaworthy although badly battered, and she was prepared for the venture. Loaded with concrete and explosives she set out again on May 9 with Commodore H. Lynes as before in. command of the . new enterprise. Sir Roger Keyes, who had been made a K.C.B. for the earlier achievement, was again present in the Warwick. Commander A. E. Godsal, R.N., who had taken the Brilliant in, was in command of the block-ship, and Engineer Lieutenant-Commander W. A. Bury, R.N., who had taken the Vindictive into Zeebrugge on St. George's Day, remained in charge of the machinery with his assistants and some volunteers. The Germans were again surprised, and on this occasion a fortunate breeze blew away the fog that hid the entrance between the two piers and enabled the ship to steer for the opening. She was helped by a coastal motor-boat under Lieutenant W. R. Slayter, R.N., which burned a flare on the spot from which the Stroom Back buoy had been removed by the enemy. Two motor- boats under Lieutenants A. L. Poland, R.N., and A. Dayrell-Reed, D.S.O., R.N.R., went ahead and torpedoed the pier ends while the monitors and seaplanes bombarded the batteries on shore. The Germans replied with every gun that would bear, and under a hail of projectiles the Vindictive steamed full speed for the entrance, where another motor-boat commanded by Lieutenant G. L. Cockburn, R.N., had laid a burning light buoy. The official narrative says, then:
The guns found her at once. The after control was demolished by a shell which killed all its occupants, including Sub-Lieutenant Angus H. MacLachlan, who was in command of it. Commander Godsal ordered his officers to go with him into the conning tower. The Vindictive laid her battered nose to the eastern pier and prepared to swing her 320 feet of length across the channel. At that moment a shell from the shore batteries struck the conning-tower. Lieutenant Sir John Alleyne and Lieutenant V. A. C. Crutchley were still within. Lieutenant Alleyne was stunned by the shock; Lieutenant Crutchley shouted through the slit to the Commander, and, receiving no answerfor Commander Godsal had been blown to pieces by the bursting shell rang the port engine full speed astern, to help in swinging the ship. She was lying at an angle of about 40 degrees to the pier, and seemed to be hard and fast. Lieutenant Crutchley therefore gave the order to clear the engine-room and abandon ship. Engineer Lieutenant-Commander Bury, who was the last man to leave the engine-room, blew the main charges by the switch installed aft. Lieutenant Crutchley blew the auxiliary charges in the forward 6-inch magazine. The old ship sank about six feet and lay upon the bottom of the channel. Her work was done. . . .
The losses were comparatively light, and most of these were incurred by the Vindictive's crew when leaving the ship. In the whole operation four officers and six men were killed, five officers and 26 men wounded, and nine men missing. The survivors were taken off in a motor launch by Lieutenants R. Bourke and G. H. Drummond, R.N.V.R. The only casualty in material was the launch commanded by the latter officer, who was himself severely wounded with several of his men, while his second in command, Lieutenant Gordon Ross, R.N.V.R., and one man was killed. The badly damaged boat was sunk after the wounded had been transferred to the Warwick.
It was not claimed that the channels at Zeebrugge and Ostend were completely sealed, but for all practical purposes, as centres of torpedo craft activity, the two ports were immobilized and Bruges was deprived of its value as a torpedo base.