NORMAN THORPE AND TOM MORGAN
We can't remember exactly when we first heard the term "The Thankful Villages" but whenever it was, we also learned what a Thankful Village was, although we only had vague definitions at the time.
The phrase was first used by Arthur Mee in his King's England series in the 1930s. A Thankful Village, it was said, was one which lost no men in the Great War because all those who left to serve came home again. For example, in Yorkshire East Riding he says about Catwick, "Thirty men went from Catwick to the Great War and thirty came back, though one left an arm behind." It was also said that such villages have no war memorials - or that if they do, they are a thankful reminder of all who served. Any community which enjoyed this rare distinction must have been Thankful indeed, in an age when family and community life broken by war was the norm.
In the early days of the Internet, one of us (Tom) asked a question about The Thankful Villages in what was then the only discussion forum related to the Great War. There were few replies, and none which actually named any villages. But the record of that question remained and as it was just about the only Internet reference to The Thankful Villages, it showed up whenever anyone else used a Search Engine to look for information using that phrase. Because Tom was one of the few traceable people who had mentioned the subject on the Internet, he received a small number of emails over the next few years, asking for more information, but always knew no more nor less than the questioner.
Tom received one such email from Norman. We were unable to exchange much information, but we parted company with an agreement to let each other know if we discovered anything more. About a year later, Norman re-established the contact, having spent some time digging around for information on The Thankful Villages.
We think that between us, we have established the most accurate up-to-date listing of the possible Thankful Villages identified by Norman, given the research resources and opportunity at our disposal. The names of the villages on our lists came from several sources: books by Arthur Mee and also from The Daily Mail, The Guardian, Stand To! (the journal of the Western Front Association) and individual correspondents. Several of these correspondents e-mailed us after hearing about this article on Radio 4's "Making History" and finding it on the BBC website. All the names for which "Thankful Village Status" are claimed in these original sources appear in one of the lists below.
Each of the villages has been checked against the data held on the "Soldiers Died in the Great War" CD-ROM. The data includes, for each soldier who died, his place-of-birth, his place-of-enlistment and his place-of-residence. However, many soldiers' entries have the place-of-residence field left blank.
It should be noted that the CD-ROM contains information ONLY about OTHER RANKS of the BRITISH ARMY. The companion "Officers Died in the Great War" does not give any places of birth, residence or enlistment for officers. The CD-ROM does not include those who died while serving in the Royal Navy (including the 63rd (Royal Naval) Division), Royal Marines or Royal Air Force. Nor does it include soldiers who served in the armies of Canada, Australia or any other Dominion Forces. Our conclusions should be read with this in mind. We have also added the names of villages which have been suggested by readers of this article and these villages, with our reasons for accepting or disqualifying them, are given in footnotes.
We have begun to create sub-pages, with further details about the villages today, and what "Thankful Village-related" items can be seen. The villages already included are underlined in our lists, and clicking on the village name will take you to the sub-page. On each page is a further link which will return you to this article at the point where you left it. If any readers have local knowledge and would like to submit photographs or brief written decriptions, we would be pleased to hear from them via the email link at the bottom of this page.
LIST ONE
This list contains the names of those villages which have no mention on the
CD-ROM. That is, these villages have no soldiers recorded as having
died. (In the case of a village where there is no figure for the number of
men, this could be because not even one man served in the army, though this
is unlikely.) This list also contains villages with soldiers who died stated
to have been born there, but also stated to be residing elsewhere
and we have assumed that in these cases, such men would be included among
the war dead from their places-of-residence.
These then, would appear to be real Thankful Villages.
| County | Village | Grid Ref | Men | Notes |
| Buckinghamshire | Stoke Hammond | SP 8829 | -- |
See note (ii) below |
| Cardiganshire | Llanfihangel-y-Creuddyn | SN 6676 | -- |
See note (xi) below |
| Cornwall | Herodsfoot | SX 2160 | See note (viii) below | |
Derbyshire |
Bradbourne | SK 2152 | 18 |
|
Essex |
Strethall | TL 4939 | -- |
|
Glamorgan |
Colwinston | SS 9475 | 23 |
|
Gloucestershire |
Brierley | SO 6215 | 14 |
|
Gloucestershire |
Coln Rogers | SP 0809 | 25 |
War Memorial also lists one woman - Doris Barton VAD |
Gloucestershire |
Little Sodbury | ST 7683 | 6 |
|
| Herefordshire | Middleton-on-the-Hill | SO 5464 | -- |
See note (i) below |
Hertfordshire |
Puttenham | SP 8814 | 15 |
|
Kent |
Knowlton | TR 2853 | 12 |
"Bravest Village" - see note (ix) below |
| Lancashire | Arkholme | SD 5871 | 59 |
One "soldier died" born there but "residence" blank * |
Lancashire |
Nether Kellett | SD 5168 | -- |
One soldier was awarded the DCM |
| Leicestershire | Saxby | SK 8220 | -- |
|
| Lincolnshire | Bigby | TA 0607 | 10 |
One "soldier died" born there but "residence" blank * |
| Lincolnshire | Claxby | TF 1194 | See note (vii) below | |
| Lincolnshire | Flixborough | SE 8715 | -- |
See note (vii) below |
| Lincolnshire | High Toynton | TF 2870 | 14 |
One "soldier died" born there but resident elsewhere |
| Northamptonshire | East Carlton | SP 8389 | 7 |
See note (x) below |
| Northamptonshire | Woodend | SP 6149 | 19 |
One "soldier died" born there but resident elsewhere |
| Northumberland | Meldon | NZ 1284 | -- |
|
| Nottinghamshire | Cromwell | SK 8062 | -- |
Two "soldiers died" born there but resident elsewhere |
| Nottinghamshire | Maplebeck | SK7160 | 2 |
See note (v) below |
Nottinghamshire |
Wigsley | SK 8670 | 7 |
|
| Nottinghamshire | Wysall | SK 6027 | 12 |
See note (iv) below |
| Rutland | Teigh | SK 8616 | 11 |
One "soldier died" born there but resident elsewhere |
| Shropshire | Harley | SJ 5901 | 20 |
See note (vi) below |
| Somerset | Aisholt | ST 1935 | 8 |
|
| Somerset | Chantry | ST 7247 | -- |
One "soldier died" born there but "residence" blank * |
Somerset |
Chelwood | ST 6462 | 4 |
One "soldier died" born there but resident elsewhere |
| Somerset | Rodney Stoke | ST 4850 | 17 |
One "soldier died" born there but "residence" blank * |
| Somerset | Stocklinch | ST 3817 | 19 |
One "soldier died" born there but resident elsewhere |
| Somerset | Tellisford | ST 8055 | 3 |
|
| Somerset | Woolley | ST 7568 | 13 |
One "soldier died"born there but resident elsewhere |
| Suffolk | Culpho | TM 2149 | -- |
|
| Suffolk | South Elmham St. Michael | TM 3484 | 11 |
One "soldier died" born there but "residence" blank * |
| Yorkshire | Catwick | TA 1345 | 30 |
One "soldier died" born there but resident elsewhere |
| Yorkshire | Cundall | SE 4272 | 12 |
|
| Yorkshire | Norton-le-Clay | SE 4071 | 16 |
|
| Yorkshire | Scruton | SE 3092 | -- |
See note (iii) below |
* But Commonwealth War Graves Commission records show residence elsewhere(i) Ben Bydawell has pointed out that Middleton-on-the-Hill in Herefordshire, has a stone column in St. Mary's churchyard commemorating the fact that all the men from the village who served in the Great War and Second World War returned safely. The column is topped by a lantern and bears the inscription, "A thank offering to Almighty God (beneath this it says, "At evening time it shall be light") for the safe return of all the men from this parish who fought in the Great War 1914 - 1918 and 1939 - 1945." Middleton-on-the-Hill doesn't show up anywhere in the 'Soldiers Died in the Great War' database so we include it as a Thankful Village.
(ii) There are three soldiers listed as having been born in Stoke Hammond, Buckinghamshire. Two of them are recorded as living elsewhere and the third soldier, Private William Harry Curtis of the Machine Gun Corps (Cavalry) has no place of residence listed. However there is a "William Curtis" listed on the war memorial at Whaddon, near Milton Keynes, Bucks. There is no soldier called Curtis listed as having been born in Whaddon. Of the 55 "soldiers died" with the surname Curtis and William as a forename, only one other has any Buckinghamshire connection and this is a soldier born and resident in High Wycombe. We conclude that the "William Curtis" named on the Whaddon memorial is the "William Harry Curtis" listed as having been born at Stoke Hammond, just seven miles away. On the basis of this conclusion we have included Stoke Hammond as a Thankful Village. We are grateful to Bill Kirk of Stoke Hammond for bringing the village to our attention and also to Will O'Brien who located the name of Pte. Curtis on the Whaddon War memorial.
(iii) Scruton, Yorkshire, was originally included in our List 2 as there was one "soldier died" (66641Pte. E. H. Corps, Northumberland Fusiliers) born there but with no place of residence recorded. However Janet Crampton, Chair of Scruton Parish Council, has discovered that Pte. Corps lived at Aske in the Parish of Easby, near Richmond, before he enlisted, and is named on the War Memorial at Easby. Scruton thus had three "soldiers died" who were born there, all of whom were living elsewhere at the time of their deaths and by our definition, Scruton is therefore a Thankful Village."
(iv) The village of Wysall, Nottinghamshire was originally included in our List 2 because there was one casualty (23778 Pte. W. O. Orridge, 9th Battalion, The Leicestershire Regiment) recorded as having been born there, but with no place-of-residence given. The Gotham and District Royal British Legion, who have carried out a thorough survey of records for their own purposes, are able to confirm that a soldier with the same name, number and regimental details is commemorated at Old Dalby, not far from Melton Mowbray, where Pte. Orridge is known to have enlisted. We are grateful to Mike Elliott, Clerk to Wysall Parish Council, for discovering all this and for helping to confirm Wysall's status as a Thankful Village.
(v) Maplebeck, Nottinghamshire. The CD-ROM names a soldier, 64933 Pte. Harold Thomas WRIGHT (King's Own Yorkshire Light Infantry) as born there but with no place of residence recorded. The birthplace is confirmed by the "Where Born" entry in the 1901 Census, which also shows the family to be living at 29 Whitfield Street, Newark, Notts. This accords with the baptism entry in the Parish Register of Maplebeck:- "3 June 1900 bap Harold Thomas, son of Thomas and Sarah Ann Wright of Newark, Joiner. (Born 21 Sep 1899)". Sarah Ann née Scott lived in Mapleback until married:- "31 Dec 1896... Spinster of Maplebeck... to Thomas Wright... Joiner of Blyth" (Notts. SK 6287). So it is probable that Harold Thomas was born at his grandparents' house in Maplebeck. It appears that Harold Thomas Wright was never resident in Maplebeck even though he was born there.
Buried in Maplebeck churchyard is SE/21081 Pte. Arthur Ernest WILLIAMS (Royal Army Veterinary Corps) who died in 1917 in Manchester Royal Infirmary. He is not named in the CD-ROM but he is listed in the records of the Commonwealth War Graves Commission. Like Thomas Wright, he married a Maplebeck woman Ada Louise née White on 3 June 1914 at Maplebeck Parish Church. The CWGC entry recording his burial at Maplebeck states that he was "born at Harby, Lincoln" and was "the husband of Ada L. Williams of Ollerton, Newark." It thus appears that he was not a resident of Maplebeck.
On our behalf, Catherine Duckworth of the Lancashire County Library has asked a number of librarians in Nottinghamshire, including Ollerton and Newark, to see if they could locate either of the above soldiers on their district Roll of Honour. Their names have not been found. We are most grateful to her, and also to Malcolm Dexter of Maplebeck who provided us with details of the 1901 Census and the Maplebeck Parish Records. We conclude that Maplebeck is a Thankful Village.
(vi) Harley, Shropshire, was brought to our attention by Dave Trenberth, who informs us that a memorial inside St. Mary's Church names 20 men from the village who served in the Great War. The memorial has the significant inscription, 'By the Grace of God every one of these men returned to the Parish after the War'. We can find no reference to any "soldier died" who was a resident of Harley (although there was one "soldier died" born there but resident elsewhere) so on the evidence of the memorial, we conclude that Harley is a Thankful Village.
(vii) Thanks to Charles Anderson for information on Flixborough, which has a window in the parish church "Dedicated to the Glory of God And in Thankfulness for the safe return of those from this parish who served in the Wars 1914 - 18, 1939 - 45. "Soldiers Died in the Great War" records no soldier died as being a resident.
Charles also drew Claxby near Market Rasen to our attention. It has no War Memorial for WWI though there is one for WWII. The CD-ROM does not list any 'soldier died' as a resident of this Claxby (but there is one listed as resident at another Claxby, near Alford, at TF 4571).
(viii) Thanks to Andrew Brice for information on Herodsfoot. "Soldiers Died in the Great War" records no soldier as being a resident. Herodsfoot has a war memorial, but the inscription refers only to "those who served."
(ix) Knowlton was adjudged the Bravest Village in England in a competition organised by the Weekly Dispatch in 1914 for sending the biggest percentage of its population to the colours. 12 men joined up out of a total population of only 39. The 17 ft. high memorial cross given by the Weekly Dispatch to mark the Bravest Village still stands.
(x) Thanks to Rosalind Willatts for the nominating East Carlton, which has a memorial in the Parish Church commemorating 7 men who served, and mentioning no casualties. "Soldiers Died in the Great War" records no residents.
(xi) The CD-ROM lists only one 'soldier died' with residence stated to be "Llanfihangel, Cardigan". There were two villages of that name in this county. The soldier was 31548 Pte. E.T. Richards, 8th Bn. Royal Welsh Fusiliers, who died 4 November, 1915. On our behalf, Catherine Duckworth of the Lancashire County Library asked the library at Aberystwyth for assistance. Nia Richards of Aberystwyth located the name of Pte. Richards in the Roll of Honour at Llanfihangel Geneu'r Glyn. So Llanfihangel-y-Creuddyn meets our criterion for inclusion as a Thankful Village. We thank Catherine and Nia for their willing help.
Thankful Village in France
Thank you to Prof. Dr. Stefan Fisch who occupies the Chair of Modern and Contemporary History at the German University of Administrative Sciences at Speyer. He has drawn our attention to an entry on page 196 of "Grand Inventaire du Génie Français" by Jérôme Duhamel (Paris 1990). Translated into English, it says,"Between 1919 and 1925, a war memorial was erected in every community in France, with one single exception: the village of Thierville in the department of the Eure, the only French village which had no dead to mourn, not in 1870, nor in 14-18, nor in 39-45".
Thierville (postcode 27290) is in Normandy, 30 km. south-west of Rouen and 8km north of Brionne, between the D124 and D130 roads. From the above information we include Thierville here as a a Thankful Village, but we have not added it to the total number given in the Conclusion. This number relates only to Britain.
LIST TWO
This list is used for villages which have been put forward as Thankful Villages,
but about which there is some uncertainty or doubt. After further research,
in many cases with help from correspondents with local knowledge, we have
usually been able to transfer our "List 2 Villages" to List 1 or List 3,
with a footnote to clarify our reasons.
| County | Village | Grid Ref | Men | Notes |
| Lincolnshire | Gate Burton | SK 8382 | -- |
See note (ii) below |
| Warwickshire | Halford | SP 2545 | -- |
See note (i) below |
(i) Martyn Johnson contacted us to tell us that he believed Halford to be a Thankful Village in both world wars. However "Soldiers Died in the Great War" records two soldiers as having been born there, but with the place-of-residence left blank. Until we are able to find out where these soldiers lived, some doubt remains as to Halford's "thankful" status. The first soldier is 204317 Pte. Thomas Henry Webb, 9th Battalion, East Surrey Regiment, killed in action 17.8.17. However, the Commonwealth War Graves Commision records state that he was the husband of Laura Alice Webb, of 1744, Pershore Rd, Cotteridge, King's Norton, Birmingham. The second soldier is 3486 Pte. George Thomas Trentham, 1st Battlion, Royal Warwickshire Regiment, died of wounds 8.6.15. The Commonwealth War Graves Commision (which has him wrongly named as "Trentha") has no family details.
(ii) "Soldiers Died in the Great War" lists one soldier who was born in Gate Burton - R/16819 Rifleman Arthur Hill, 9th Battalion, King's Royal Rifle Corps - who died of wounds on 21st March, 1918. Unfortunately, there is no record of Rfmn. Hill's place-of-residence. The Commonwealth War Grave Register for Rfmn. Hill's place of commemoration (the Thiepval Memorial to the Missing) has no personal or family details. Pending further research we have placed the village in our List 2, and we thank Charles Anderson for bringing Gate Burton to our attention.
LIST THREE - OTHER CLAIMANTS
These villages have also been nominated as Thankful Villages in one or other of our sources, but according to "Soldiers Died in the Great War" their claims are thrown into doubt because they each have at least one man stated as having his place-of-residence there although born elsewhere. The information in "Soldiers Died in the Great War" is assumed to have come, in the first instance, from the soldier at the time of his enlistment, and we must assume that a soldier knew where he lived. Clearly, if a soldier who died in the war lived in a particular village, then he did not return to his home in that village afterwards and this would appear to disqualify the village.
| County | Village | Grid Ref | Men | Notes |
| Bedfordshire | Stanbridge | SP 9724 | 33 |
One "soldier died" stated to be resident |
| Buckinghamshire | Swanbourne | SP 8027 | 67 |
Two "soldiers died" stated to be resident * |
| Cambridgeshire | Knapwell | TL 3363 | 23 |
One "soldier died" stated to be resident |
| Gloucestershire | Upper Slaughter | SP1523 | 44 |
Two "soldiers died" stated to be resident |
| Leicestershire | Willesley | SK 3415 | 3 |
One "soldier died" stated to be resident |
| Norfolk | Ovington | TF 9202 | 14 |
One "soldier died" stated to be resident See note (iv) |
| Shropshire | Pulverbatch | SJ 4202 | 49 |
See note (v) below |
| Somerset | Priddy | ST 5350 | 38 |
Three "soldiers died" stated to be resident |
| Somerset | Stanton Prior | ST 6762 | 4 |
One "soldier died" stated to be resident |
| Suffolk | Gisleham | TM 5188 |
-- |
See note (ii) below. One "soldier died" stated to be resident |
| Suffolk | Ilketshall St. John | TM 3687 |
-- |
See note (iii) below. One resident listed on nearby memorial |
| Suffolk | Rushmere | TM 4987 | -- |
Three "soldiers died" stated as resident ** |
| Westmorland | Morland | NY 6022 | -- |
See note (i)below. Two "soldiers died" stated to resident |
| Wiltshire | Littleton Drew | ST 8380 | 22 |
One "soldier died" stated to be resident |
| Yorkshire | Cayton | TA 0683 | 43 |
Two "soldiers died" stated to be resident *** |
* Swanbourne has a further two "soldiers died" stated as having been born there with no alternative place-of-residence given.** Rushmere has a further ten "soldiers died" stated as having been born there with no alternative place-of-residence given.
*** One from "Cayton" and one from "Cayton Bay".
(i) Sue Light informs us that while she was in France she got into conversation with a couple, who, although having no interest in the Great War, said that there is a plaque in the church at Morland, Cumbria, (then in Westmorland) just south-east of Penrith, stating that all the village men returned. However, 'Soldiers Died in the Great War' gives two men as having been born there, and one as being a resident. This is therefore not a Thankful Village.
(ii) Gisleham, Suffolk, is also put forward as a Thankful Village. There is one "Soldier Died" listed as having been born there, but with the place of residence left blank. However, the Commonwealth War Graves Commission records for this soldier, Pte. C. H. Crane, list him as "the son of David and Caroline Crane, White House lodge, Chisleham, Lowestoft." We cannot find a "Chisleham" anywhere in England, and our conclusion is that "Chisleham" is a transcription error, and that Pte. Crane was residing with his parents in his place of birth, Gisleham, which, in this case, is not a Thankful Village.
(iii) Although Ilketshall St.John, Suffolk, appears in various lists, the War Memorial in neighbouring Ilketshall St. Lawrence names a soldier from Ilketshall St. John, which is confirmed by the CD-ROM. This is therefore not a Thankful Village.
(iv) Ovington, Norfolk, was originally included in List Two because there are two "soldiers died" listed as having been born there but without places of residence given. Research has indicated another Ovington soldier, however. He was Pte G.H. Goodrick who died in Ovington on 15th November, 1918. He is not listed in "Soldiers Died in the Great War" but his burial at Watton Nonconformist Burial Ground is recorded by the Commonwealth War Graves Commission. Furthermore, the "Thetford and Watton Times" for 23 Nov 1918 says he was "of the Cock Inn, Ovington." and had "been gassed on the Western Front about six months ago." On 30th November the same newspaper reported Pte. Goodrick's funeral with full military honours and confirmed his address as "The Cock Inn, Ovington." Ovington is therefore not a Thankful Village.
(v) A Roll of Honour in St Edith's church, Pulverbatch, Shropshire, names the 49 men of the parish who served during the First World War. The memorial doesn't identify any fatalities. However, there are two "Soldiers Died" recorded as being residents of the village.
CONCLUSION
Our research is not conclusive but it does suggest that the only villages with a clear claim to "Thankfulness" are the 41 villages given in List One.We don't have expert local knowledge of every village, so perhaps there is other information to be considered. If any readers carry out any further research at local level, we would be very happy to include their research here and, if necessary, revise our listings in the light of new evidence.
For a direct link to the authors of this article, email Norman Thorpe or Tom Morgan.
Copyright © Norman Thorpe, Tom
Morgan, March 2004, June 2005
Return to the Hellfire Corner Contents Section