BOOK REVIEWS
![]() |
My Boy Jack? |
An excellent book, but not for the reasons I had expected! The back cover details describe briefly how the authors noted, in 1992, that a previously "unknown" grave had been identified as the grave of Lieut. John Kipling, and how they felt compelled to investigate further, eventually forming the opinion that the identification was incorrect - an opinion supported, according to the back-cover details - by four qualified professionals, whose judgements are included. So convincing was the authors' research, that the Ministry of Defence is now the final authority as to whether or not the identifaction is be accepted as true. The actual title of the book has the subtitle "The Search for Kipling's Only Son". Taken together, the bookshop browser might think, as I did, that the book is about the details of the previous identification and the grounds for challenging them, a sort of detective story in which the authors were going to have to ensure that their arguments met the demanding requirements of the four eminently-qualified experts referred to on the back cover.
With this expectation in mind, I began reading. What the book contains is a very full and very readable account of Kipling's life. It details his own childhood and then moves on to his marriage and, of course, his relationship with his own children inclduing his only son, John. We often hear how Kipling pulled all kinds of strings and called in all sorts of favours in order to get John, whose eyesight was appallingly bad, into the Army on the outbreak of war. What is often left out of these re-tellings of the story is that John himself was just as keen to be accepted as a soldier. Having had access to many Kipling papers, including the famous father and son's letters to each other, the authors have been able to paint a very clear picture of the special relationship which existed between them. They also manage to keep reminding us of the particular mindset of the times, which made parents refer to "giving" their sons. This seems a particularly arrogant and selfish way of describing things to us today, but Tonie and Valmai Holt place these old-fashioned concepts firmly in their place historically, so that they don't seem quite so foreign to us.
Of course there is plenty of detail, well supported by letters and other documents, about Kipling's work for the (then) Imperial War Graves Commission and for the family's search for details of exactly what had happened to John, who had been reported as missing during the Battle of Loos in 1915. They travelled all over the country interviewing former members of John's battalion and, through family and professional contacts, were able to enlist the help of some surprisingly influential people including senior members of at least two European Royal Families. But this is Kipling's search for his only son. I was getting towards the end of this very readable book and wondering when THE Search - the one suggested by the cover details, was going to begin. This does appear, but only as a 17-page epilogue out of a book of 236 pages, and this doesn't count the views of the four experts, whose opinions (the longest is only four lines long) appear on one page right at the end.
It's an excellent book about Kipling and his relationship with his public, his family and his son. It contains an epilogue which presents quite convincing evidence to suggest that the identification of the grave in St. Mary's ADS Cemetery is not sound. But to my way of reading, it isn't quite what the cover suggests it's going to be!
.My Boy Jack?
is published by Pen & Sword Books
Soft Covers
236 pages, 15 photographs
ISBN: 0-85052-859-3
Return to the Hellfire Corner Contents Section