
This book has been edited to fit the internet.
Chapter 2
SAN BERNARDINO STRAIT
Time-Line, Events, & Comments
What makes this book unique is the use of a time-line for all events, all listed in chronological, time-line order. The events in Chapters two through nine are listed in the order in which the author believes they occurred. Entries listed simply as "EVENT" are also placed in a chronological, time-line order and are closely related in time to the last numbered "time" event. Comments by the author associated with events are often listed also. Entries are displayed as follows:
| 0708 | A time-specific event, in the order in which the author believes they actually occurred. |
| EVENT | A specific event, closely related in time to the last numbered "time" event. |
| A/C | Author's Comment. A personal explanation of events by the author. |
Wednesday, October 25, 1944
| 0035 | On October 25, 1944, the Japanese Center Force, in single column, exited the restricted narrows of San Bernardino Strait unopposed and entered the Philippine Sea. All hands were alert and at their battlestations expecting the telltale flash of U.S. battleship guns. |
| A/C | The navigation of San Bernardino Strait by a large number of warships was said to be impossible by some, if not extremely hazardous. The successful piloting of the strait can be attributed to the excellent seamanship of the Japanese sailor. |
| A/C | Since the beginning of the war in the Philippines, the navigation lights marking the strait had been darkened. On this evening however, a U.S. reconnaissance aircraft reported the navigational lights had been relit. This obviously only would have been done by the Japanese forces stationed on Luzon and Samar. The U.S. fleets were under strict orders not to enter the strait for fear of Japanese mines. In fact, all internal waterways in the Philippines islands were suspected to be heavily mined. |
| A/C | Vice Admiral Kurita rightfully thought he would have to fight is way out of San Bernardino Strait. Fearing the Americans would "cross the T'" of his force as they transited the narrow strait, his ships may well have fell easy prey to the radar controlled 16-inch guns of Third Fleet's fast battleships. The Americans would clearly hold the advantage. If caught in this predicament, he would be unable to maneuver in the restricted waters of the strait with only the forward guns on his ships able to respond. The American battleline, steaming in formation across the end of the strait, would be in position to bear all their guns on the approaching fleet as it exited the strait one-by-one. All the Japanese ships would be subjected to concentrated fire as they approached the base of the American "T." |
| A/C | When it became apparent that the American fast battleships were not there to meet him, the next logical consideration under the circumstances was a submarine attack. To the admiral's relief, there were no torpedo wakes either. Shortly after the last ship exited San Bernardino Strait, they prepared to form a standard night-search disposition. |
| EVENT | Upon exiting the other side of San Bernardino Strait and entering the Philippine Sea, Center Force is ordered to head east for open ocean. They form four columns, each five kilometers apart, on a broad 13 mile front, forming a standard night-search disposition. |
| A/C | Vice Admiral Kurita still expected the Americans to resist their sortie at any moment. As Centre Force sailed along cautiously, the admiral made plans for the morning which he knew would once again bring out the American carrier borne air strikes. |
| EVENT | The Van and Rear of the Japanese Southern Forces are contacted via ship-to-ship radio by VADM Kurita and are ordered, " . . . all forces will meet at 1000 off the southern tip of Samar...." |
| A/C | This comment sounded quite casual considering what had happened to Centre Force the previous day in the Sibuyan Sea. They were by now like a fox in the hen-house, just waiting for the farmer with his shotgun to arrive. Vice Admiral Kurita was set upon making the best of his current situation and he planned accordingly. |
| EVENT | Task Unit 77.4.3, commanded by RADM C.A.F. "Ziggy" Sprague is in it's assigned night operations area off the island of Samar. It is one of the three "Taffies" providing close air support for the Leyte Gulf amphibious landing. Taffy III consists of six escort carriers, or CVE's, covered by a small screen of three destroyers and four destroyer escorts. |
| A/C | The other two Task Units of Task Group 77.4 were TU 77.4.2 (Taffy II), currently steaming in its respective operations area, approximately 30 nautical miles south of Taffy III; and TU 77.4.1 (Taffy I), steaming a further 30 nautical miles south of Taffy II. Each Task Unit had a screen of destroyers and destroyer escorts. |
| A/C | CVE's were known throughout the fleet as "Combustible," "Vulnerable," and "Expendable," or Kaiser coffins, named after their manufacturer, Kaiser Yard, Swan Island, Oregon. Taffy III's CVE's were CASABLANCA Class escort carriers; 512 feet long, 108 feet of beam, displacing 7,800 tons. Their armament consisted of a single 5-inch gun on their fantail, eight twin 40mm and twenty 20mm anti-aircraft guns. Their biggest asset were their thirty aircraft, on average they carried 12 Grumman TBM Avenger torpedo bombers and 18 Grumman FM-2 Wildcat fighters. |
| A/C | Taffy III had three FLETCHER Class destroyers in its screen. Each destroyer had five 5-inch radar controlled guns and two 5-mount torpedo tubes. The four smaller destroyer escorts had two 5-inch guns apiece without radar control and only three torpedo tubes. The destroyers were ten knots faster than the destroyer escorts and they required 100 more men. |
| EVENT | Inside the Combat Information Center aboard Taffy III screening ship DE SAMUEL B. ROBERTS all appears to be routine. Lieutenant Commander Robert W. Copeland, her commanding officer and LT Everett E. Roberts, Jr., her executive officer, listen to the radio reports of the action in Surigao Strait with great interest. |
| A/C | Both men had stayed up all night listening to the radio reports concerning the action in Surigao Strait. They probably felt at this time that this was the closest they would ever come in actual combat with an enemy surface fleet. ROBERTS was one of the smallest ships of the fleet, outfitted primarily for anti-submarine duty. The thirteen ships of Taffy III were currently in their night operating area, further out to sea than during the day when they would be conducting air operations. |
| 0100 | Nearing the entrance to Surigao Strait, VADM Nishimura gives the order for his Southern Force Van to assume it's battle order for entering the strait. Destroyer MICHISHIO leads, followed in a single line by DD ASAGUMO, BB YAMASHIRO, and BB FUSO. The heavy cruiser MOGAMI brings up the rear. Two destroyers patrol the port and starboard flanks, DD SHIGURE and DD YAMAGUMO respectively. |
| A/C | After being harassed continuously by torpedo boats, VADM Nishimura decided it was time to form his ships into their battle order. This was the formation they would use to enter Surigao Strait and battle their way into Leyte Gulf. He presently knew nothing of the American force awaiting him at the north end of the strait, nor was he coordinating his attack by waiting for VADM Shima's Rear forces to catch up with those of his own. |
| A/C | One interesting fact is that while the Southern Force Van proceeded toward Surigao Strait encountering torpedo boats along the way, after each encounter, the Van would radio VADM Kurita and VADM Shima's forces stating, "...destroying enemy torpedo boats...." Vice Admiral Nishimura communicated his actions to the Rear, yet he was unwilling, so it seemed, to join forces with them. |
| 0155 | Vice Admiral Kinkaid, Commander Seventh Fleet, orders RADM Thomas Sprague, Commander Task Group 77.4 to direct his escort carrier commander's to fly three dawn searches to cover San Bernardino Strait and it's eastern and western approaches. This is done mostly to satisfy VADM Kinkaid's curiosity. He feels quite comfortable knowing (self-convinced) VADM Lee's Task Force 34 fast battleships are guarding San Bernardino Strait. |
| 0208 | Vice Admiral Mitscher's Task Group 38 reconnaissance aircraft sight battleships ISE and HYUGA, accompanied by four destroyers. |
| 0230 | Vice Admiral Kurita receives another message from VADM Nishimura, stating that his ships have entered Surigao Strait and have met only light resistance from U.S. torpedo boats. |
| A/C | His force was in fact under attack from torpedo boats since just shortly before midnight. Thirty-nine torpedo boats were split into thirteen 3-ship groups. Their mission was to report Japanese ship movements, maintain contact, and if possible, to attack. |
| A/C | Well ahead of schedule and at his present rate of advance, VADM Nishimura's Southern Force Van would penetrate Surigao Strait and arrive in Leyte Gulf about six hours ahead of Centre Force, upsetting the GHQ plan to attack simultaneously. |
| A/C | It should have been very apparent to VADM Kurita that his two Southern Force Commanders were not coordinating their attack. The Southern Force Rear was currently about 40 miles behind the Van and was making no effort to catch up. The two admirals were simply unwilling to coordinate their forces to storm through Surigao Strait together. Unbelievably, no action was taken by VADM Kurita, nor GHQ in Tokyo, to remedy this situation. |
| 0238 | Vice Admiral Ozawa's carriers and escorts are sighted by Task Force 38 reconnaissance aircraft. Believing they are within 90 miles of his Task Force, VADM Mitscher recommends the formation of battleline, Task Force 34. Admiral Halsey approves the recommendation to form Task Force 34. |
| A/C | The Japanese carriers were actually 210 miles from the Americans. Task Force 34 was then formed and consisted of battleships WASHINGTON (flagship of VADM Lee), ALABAMA, IOWA, NEW JERSEY (flagship of ADM Halsey), MASSACHUSETTS, and SOUTH DAKOTA, heavy cruisers WICHITA and NEW ORLEANS, light cruisers VINCENNES, MIAMI, BILOXI, SANTA FE, and MOBILE, and eighteen destroyers. |
| 0300 | Well into open ocean, Center Force now turns southeast, steaming at 20 knots off the east coast of Samar. |
| 0309 | Approaching Surigao Strait in battle order, BB FUSO comes under attack by American destroyers and is hit by at least one torpedo. Numerous fires erupt and her engine room is severely damaged. The fires spread to her magazines and a tremendous explosion blows the ship into two pieces. |
| 0320 | Light cruiser ABUKUMA of the Southern Force Rear is struck by a torpedo from PT 137, killing 30 men. Unable to continue north, she is detached from the Rear by VADM Shima and is sent westward to retire at 9 knots. |
| 0320 | Destroyer MONSSEN hits BB YAMASHIRO with one torpedo. Badly damaged, two magazines are immediately flooded to avoid a possible catastrophic explosion. |
| 0320 | In what is considered the most successful American destroyer torpedo attack of the entire war, the destroyer McDERMUT cripples the Van's destroyers MICHISHIO and ASAGUMO, and sinks YAMAGUMO outright, which explodes so violently, it is seen 20 miles away by RADM Oldendorf in LOUISVILLE. |
| A/C | This was the beginning of the highly effective American destroyer attacks in Surigao Strait. The American destroyers approached in groups of three, launched their torpedoes, and retired at high speed back up the strait. At this time several destroyers came under intense fire but none were hit. During this phase of the battle, several Japanese ships were crippled or sunk. Battleships YAMASHIRO and FUSO are both seriously damaged by the attacks. |
| 0330 | Rear Admiral Thomas Sprague, Commander Task Group 77.4, orders Taffy II to provide aircraft for dawn searches over the approaches to San Bernardino Strait. The message is received an hour late by RADM Stump on CVE KADASHAN BAY and he later tasks CVE OMMANEY BAY with the mission. Ten Avengers are prepared for this mission on a rain-soaked deck but the planes are not ready to fly until almost 0700. |
| A/C | The Philippine tropical weather, notably the rainy season, was taking its toll on air operations. |
| A/C | In addition to their reconnaissance duties, the escort carriers were also notified to standby to attack the Japanese stragglers from the Battle of Surigao Strait. Because of this order, many of the CVE's were prepared to launch aircraft with torpedoes and semi-armour piercing bombs to deal with the stragglers of the Battle of Surigao Strait. Unknown by the CVE commanders, this planning would pay off ten-fold later in the morning during the Battle Off Samar. |
| 0335 | Vice Admiral Kurita receives another message from VADM Nishimura's Van stating his force has sighted three enemy ships. |
| A/C | The worst was yet to come for the Van. Rear Admiral Jesse Oldendorf had assembled a large reception for the Japanese forces approaching Leyte Gulf from the south. On station northwest of Hibuson island at the northern entrance to Surigao Strait were all six old battleships, four heavy cruisers, and four light cruisers. |
| 0351 | The right and left flank cruisers open fire with their main batteries on the approaching Van. |
| A/C | YAMASHIRO was about eleven and one-half miles from the Seventh Fleet battleline when the order to open fire was given. The heavy cruisers were stationed about three and one-half miles south of the battleships, closer to the approaching Japanese. Vice Admiral Nishimura's remaining forces were met with a torrential downfall of 16, 14, 8, and 6-inch shells. |
| 0353 | Battleship WEST VIRGINIA opens fire with her 16-inch main batteries on the Van. |
| 0355 | Battleships' CALIFORNIA and TENNESSEE open fire with their 14-inch main batteries on the Van. |
| 0358 | Destroyer MICHISHIO is hit by several torpedoes from destroyer HUTCHINS and sinks almost instantly. |
| 0359 | Battleship MARYLAND opens fire with her 16-inch main batteries on the Van. |
| A/C | Only DD SHIGURE survived the onslaught of RADM Oldendorf's battleline. They defended the strait brilliantly by crossing the enemy's "T", a tactic which had become the envy of battleline commanders since the day of the Japanese-Russo one-sided duel in Tsushima Strait in May 1905. Oldendorf's battleline was deployed across the northern end of Surigao Straight with all guns bearing southward on the approaching Japanese warships. When the Van initially approached, torpedo boats first attacked, followed by the destroyers. Rear Admiral Oldendorf's six old battleships, cruisers, and assorted vessels made quick work of the Southern Force Van. Battleships YAMASHIRO and FUSO were sunk outright, as were most of the other unfortunate ships. |
| 0400 | Center Force changes course to 150 and steams nearly southward, 10 miles off the coast of Samar. |
| EVENT | Vice Admiral Shima's Southern Force Rear warships proceed northward up the approach to Surigao Strait at 28 knots. His four destroyers lead, followed by heavy cruisers NACHI and ASHIGARA. |
| EVENT | Vice Admiral Shima shortly thereafter sights what appears to be two burning ships in the water ahead. He immediately concludes they are the Van's two battleships FUSO and YAMASHIRO. Next he sights the Van's retreating destroyer SHIGURE, which is having rudder difficulties. Heavy cruiser NACHI and DD SHIGURE exchange recognition communications and SHIGURE continues southward. |
| A/C | The two burning ships VADM Shima sighted were in fact the two separate halves of BB FUSO. After DD SHIGURE encountered VADM Shima's Rear, the retreating destroyer proceeded southward without giving any information to the advancing Rear about the demise of the Van. This was another clear indication of their lack of coordination and communications which plagued the entire southern pincher operation. |
| EVENT | The Van's CA MOGAMI Is sighted "dead in the water" by the advancing Rear forces. Although she has been hard hit, MOGAMI is still making way, unknown by VADM Shima's advancing Rear forces. |
| 0409 | Last of the battleships to do so, MISSISSIPPI opens fire with her 14-inch main batteries on the Southern Force Van just after the word to cease-fire is given by RADM Oldendorf. |
| A/C | Battleship MISSISSIPPI had great difficulty locating a target for her guns; she finally ranged off of the other ship's shell fall. |
| A/C | The order to cease fire was given by RADM Oldendorf because the American destroyer ALBERT W. GRANT of CDR Smoot's DESRON 56 was repeatedly hit by friendly shell fire from 0407 onward. This was to be the only significant damage suffered by the Americans during the Battle of Surigao Strait, except for a few unlucky PT boats which received only minor damage. |
| A/C | Although the amount of ordnance placed on the Southern Force Van was great, of the six old battleships present, only four fired more than one salvo. Battleship WEST VIRGINIA led with 93 rounds of 16-inch armor-piercing shells. TENNESSEE came in second with 69 14-inch shells, and CALIFORNIA managed 63. MARYLAND's 16-inch guns fired 48. Due to their antiquated fire-control radar, MISSISSIPPI fired only one salvo and PENNSYLVANIA none at all. Because of their lack of armour-piercing ammunition, the battleplan required the battleships to withhold their fire until the Japanese had approached to within 20,000 yards. |
| A/C | The cruisers on the other hand, fired their main batteries in rapid fire mode. Rear Admiral Oldendorf's left flank cruiser COLUMBIA fired 1,000 rounds alone. This number is astounding when you consider the total number of shells fired by the cruisers was 3,100. Two ships of this group, PHOENIX and BOISE, fire their main batteries in continuous rapid fire and later slowed to conserve ammunition. |
| 0412 | Vice Admiral Kinkaid and his staff meet during the Battle of Surigao Strait and review Seventh Fleet tasking for the day's upcoming events. The battle in Surigao Strait is coming off like clock work. Vice Admiral Kinkaid and his staff are extremely pleased with RADM Oldendorf's success. |
| EVENT | At the recommendation of an aide VADM Kinkaid is urged to contact Third Fleet to confirm the status of Task Force 34's location in San Bernardino Strait. |
| EVENT | Seventh Fleet sends ADM Halsey the following message inquiry: "...QUESTION. IS TF 34 GUARDING SAN BERNARDINO STRAIT?" It wasn't. Subsequently, the message is not received by Admiral Halsey until 0648. |
| 0419 | Vice Admiral Nishimura's flagship BB YAMASHIRO, severely damaged by the battleline, is hit on her port side by two torpedoes from the DD NEWCOMB. Unable to sustain further damage, she finally sinks, taking with her, VADM Nishimura. |
| 0420 | Southern Force Rear heavy cruisers NACHI and ASHIGARA prepare to launch a torpedo attack against two targets gained on their surface radar. |
| EVENT | Shortly thereafter, VADM Shima's heavy cruisers launch eight torpedoes apiece by radar. Heavy cruiser NACHI then literally runs into trouble. Unaware that the Van's CA MOGAMI is making way, CA NACHI is struck on her port side by the Van's damaged heavy cruiser, causing serious damage to both ships. As a result, CA NACHI is forced to retire to assess her damage. |
| A/C | The Southern Force Van's piecemeal destruction was closely followed by the Rear's retreat. Vice Admiral Shima, upon seeing the fate of VADM Nishimura's force, knew he was out-gunned and quickly chose not to go any further. This was the American high-water mark of the Battle of Leyte Gulf which was soon followed by shortly thereafter, farther to the north, the Battle Off Samar. What would transpire next off it's namesake island is justly co-titled "The Tragedy of Taffy III." |
| EVENT | Aboard Taffy III's DE ROBERTS in her Combat Information Center, word is heard over the radio that the Japanese fleet has been routed in Surigao Strait. As a result, her Commanding Officer, LCDR Copeland, is lulled into a false sense of security. |
| 0430 | All ships in Taffy III go to General Quarters for morning air operations. Planes assigned to Combat Air Patrol, anti-submarine patrol, and reconnaissance duties are readied and launched before sunrise. |
| 0530 | Taffy III completes the launching of a Combat Air Patrol consisting of 12 fighters to protect the shipping in Leyte Gulf. Later, four torpedo bombers and two more fighters are launched for an anti-submarine patrol sweep in the same area. Aircraft to safeguard Taffy III are also launched. |
| 0532 | Admiral Kurita receives a message from RADM Shima, Southern Force Rear Commander, stating that VADM Nishimura's Southern Force Van "has been destroyed." |
| 0545 | Rear Admiral Thomas Sprague's Task Unit 77.4.1 (Taffy I) launches aircraft to pursue the fleeing remanent of the Japanese Southern Forces in Surigao Strait. |
| 0551 | Ensign Hans L. Jensen is launched from Taffy II's CVE KADASHAN BAY in his TBM-1C for an anti-submarine patrol mission in the waters off Samar. |
| 0600 | The thirteen ships of Taffy III steam northward off the coast of Samar in their assigned operations area, unaware of the impending danger from the Japanese Center Force. |
| 0614 | Sunrise. |
| A/C | The new day's sun rose slowly with partly overcast skys and occasional rain squalls, typical for this time of year. |
| 0630 | Aboard Taffy III flagship CVE FANSHAW BAY, RADM Clifton Sprague sends a signal by TBS directing all ships of Taffy III to "...secure from General Quarters and set Condition 3, normal underway watches...." |
| A/C | The men of Taffy III considered the "busy work" for the morning over. The first aircraft of the new day were launched without incident. The men of Task Unit 77.4.3 would now enjoy breakfast, relax a while, and prepare for another busy day of providing air support for the invasion troops landed on Leyte. |
Back to Chapter 1 - A Glorious Opportunity
Forward to Chapter 3 - "General Attack"
Honor the Missing in Action and Killed in Action of Taffy III
We do remember. We won't forget.