Reviews and comments on
Black Cross/Red Star, vol 1

* Canadian Military History Book Review Supplement, May 2001:

"In spite of the scale of the campaign, the air war in the east is imperfectly understood. The historical record on both sides has been dramatically distorted, so that, as the authors note, 'when comparing Soviet/Russian literature with corresponding Western accounts, one wonders if they at all describe the same war.' It is to correct these misconceptions that the authors have written the first in a four-volume history of the air war in the east. They have returned to the archival sources in Germany and Russia to produce what is arguably the best, most comprehensive account of the aerial campaign. Lavishly illustrated with many rare photographs from Russian and German sources, Black Cross/Red Star belongs on the bookshelf of any serious student of aerial combat."

* Jon Guttman in Military Heritage, May 2001:

"With its clarity in showing the reader both the forest and the trees, Black Cross/Red Star us a commendable achievement. If the other three volumes in this series prove to be as well done as the first, they will provide scholars of aerial warfare with a long-overdue study of what, in terms of numbers of aircraft and land area involved, constitute the largest aerial campaign of World War II"

* FlyPast, May 2001:

"With increasing changes in the former Soviet Union, access to archive material is at last producing a balanced account of the Eastern Front and the incredible battles staged there. This is Volume 1 of what looks set to be an impressive series covering the air war element of what Stalin termed the Great Patriotic War. Stacked with appendices, references, and illustrations, this tome tells the tale of Operation Barbarossa, when Germany moved east against its former ally."

 

* M. Morozov, Senior Research Officer of the Military History Institute of MO RF (Russian Federation's Ministry of Defence):

"In the mass of literature dealing with the Great Patriotic War there are only few books that attempt to describe the air battle 1941 - 1945 from the viewpoints of both sides. Bergström's and Mikhailov's work has every right to claim that it is the most successful work that has ever been made in this direction."

 

* J.J. Fedorowicz Publishing, Inc. and Tiger Hobbies:

"Black Cross, Red Star ... an indispensable reference – highly recommended."

Read the complete review at: http://www.jjfpub.mb.ca/newstuff.htm

 

* Review by Richard Goldblatt at SimHqCom, March 2001:

"Black Cross/Red Star doesn’t make for light, casual reading, but it is without a doubt one of the finest aviation history books I’ve ever read."

Read the complete review at:

http://www.simhq.com/simhq3/sims/features/library/il-2/index2.shtml

 

* Hans-Ekkehard Bob, Major a.D. and former Staffelkapitän 9./JG 54 Grünherz. Ritterkreuzträger:
"Black Cross-Red Star is a lovely book. I wish you all the best luck, since this is an objective account."

* Hansgeorg Bätcher, Major a.D. and former bomber pilot with KG 27, KGr 100/KG 100, KG 4, and finally Kommodore KG(J) 54. Träger des Eichenlaubs zum Ritterkreuz:
"I salute the work by Mr Christer Bergström and Mr Andrey Mikhailov, which gives an objective description of the air war over Russia. . . I hope that this book will find a broad audience, and I find that it will contribute to dismantle the hostilities between our peoples."

* Aleksandr Pavlichenko, Guards Polkovnik, former pilot in 210 BBAP and 108 GShAP:
"I believe that this is the first work that tells the true story about us."

 

Aleksandr Pavlichenko, March 2001.

Photo: Vlad Antipov.

 

* Arkadiy F. Kovachevich, General-Leytenant, former fighter pilot in 27 IAP and 9 GIAP, Hero of the Soviet Union:
"I am very glad that this book has been issued. It is magnificent. I am sure that due to this book, the Russian pilots and their persistent fight against fascism will not be forgotten. For this I am grateful toward the authors of this work."

* Viktor A. Grubich, Kapitan, former bomber pilot in 615 NBAP:
"It simply is a superb work."

Review on Black Cross/Red Star by Bill Stone on Stone & Stone's reference Web site

* Robert Forsyth, Chief Editor, Classic Publications:
"It's a damned good book, and the authors should be proud of it. Congratulations. One hell of a daunting subject to tackle and I am really looking forward to reading it and ALL the other volumes - I'll just keep buying them until I either run out of money or you stop writing!"

* George Mellinger, Soviet aviation historian and author:
"This is the sort of work which needs to be done, and the direction in which aviation history should go. If you finish all five volumes,I believe it will become a true classic."

* Vlad Antipov, Russian aviation historian:
"Black Cross-Red Star is magnificent. Both I and several veterans from the war agree that this is a deep and well-researched study of a forgotten part of the war."

* Robert E. Wartburg, review on Amazon.com:
"Black Cross Red Star Review The beginning chapter states: 'Although the largest air war in history was fought on the Eastern Front during World War II, this is one of the least known chapters of aviation history.
' An opening sentence never rang so true.
Millions of pages have been written about the aerial conflict over Western Europe over the decades since the war. Given the number of units and aircraft involved over the Eastern Front, this part of aviation lore has been sadly neglected. Part of the reason has to due with the availability of the records. Only with the recent fall of the Iron Curtain have researchers been allowed more than limited access to Soviet records. Christer Bergstrom and Andrey Mikhailov are two such men who spent years interviewing the pilots who fought and suffered in the skies of Eastern Europe.
The book begins with a comparison of the two air forces involved which includes their relative experience prior to June 22, 1941, training standards, tactical doctrine and aircraft. The effect of Stalin's purges on leading airmen and aircraft engineers and its effect on the Russian Air Force is also detailed. Of interest is the German fighter pilot's 'hunting' philosophy that stressed individual achievement through aerial victories.
The beginning of the book takes the reader from the early morning dawn of June 22, 1941 to the first intense struggles for air supremacy during those first, fateful weeks. Testimonials and first-hand accounts from participants, on both sides, give humanity to the plentiful and detailed facts and figures. Many future and high scoring aces of the Luftwaffe and VVS describe their first missions during the opening battles.
One of the overall strengths of this work is that information from the antagonists is presented. Most of what we now of the air war on the Eastern Front are from the Luftwaffe point of view. Rarely did a reader know what was happening on the "Other Side of the Hill". Bergstrom and Mikhailov have made it a point to give a balanced account and include as much detail about the VVS and its pilots, as with the Luftwaffe.
After the initial stages of the air war, the authors walk the reader through the intense battles in the Ukraine, Kiev, and the desperate defense of Moscow and Leningrad. Interestingly, the VVS air raids against Berlin are documented. This is just another example of the obscure events of the war above the Eastern Front chronicled in this book.
A weakness of the book is the quality of the maps. Most of the geographical place names are blurred, making them difficult if not impossible to read. Several of the photographs have the same problem with blurring. Overall, the quality of the maps and photos do not detract significantly from the work.
I would recommend this book to anyone with even the slightest interest in the battles between the Luftwaffe and VVS. The book closes a large gap between the air war on the Eastern Front and the other theaters of war that have been heavily documented."

* Richard Powers, review on Luftwaffe Discussion Board:
"BC/RS is a large sized book with 307 pages. Main text is 257 pages the rest being appendices, notes, sources and index. 'Asources' is interesting, being the first I've seen that includes Internet sources, including this forum.
The text is well-written and very balanced for Luftwaffe and VVS coverage. And although fighters seem to get the lion's share of text, bombers, dive-bombers and ground-attack activity is well covered. Losses and claims are compared to actual loss reports for both sides where possible.
The book is arranged in chapters covering a particular area for a specific frame. This works well to keep the reader focused on what could be a confusding narrative if each chapter covered a time over the whole eastern front. I must admit that although I have read a lot of LW histories, I haven't read much about the eastern front. This book fills a void. It is wonderfully readable and full of interesting tidbits and facts.
For instance:
VVS bombing raids against Berlin in August 1941.
Werner Mölders flying 'unofficial' combat missions while visiting the eastern front as Inspector of Fighters.
'Zveno' concept of two I-16 fighters equipped with bombs under the wings of a TB-3. These were carried near the target and air launched to complete the bombing mission and then fly home.
VVS use of RS-82 rockets against ground targets, even at this early stage of the war.
Photographs are well selected, relevant to the text and have informative captions. Most of them are new. My only complaint is that the photo reproduction is not up to the quality in other recent books. Even photos that are included in Osprey publications (and there are two) seem to suffer in quality.
Altogether, I recommend this book. I know I will buy the next volume and the one after that, and the one after that . . . will it REALLY be a year?"

* A reader, on Luftwaffe Discussion Board, August 16, 2000:
"I have the book now, it's amazing, can't wait for the next volume to go online."

* Edward C. Eisler, a reader:
"I enjoyed this book very much. I can't wait to read the other volumes. It really is a great work."

* Tony Belobrajdic, Australian aviation artist:
"A very good book-excellent!"

* James Quinn, on Russian Military Forum, August 21, 2000:
"Congratulations! A very handsome job by the publisher. Nice artwork, high quality throughout."

* Andrey Dikov, Russian aviation historian:
"This book is just fantastic! Very impressive and an extensive work! I'm sure that no one has done anything similar before. I find it a balanced and neutral account on the Russo-German war-which is what all previously published works have lacked."

* Bob Rinder, a reader:
"I am so pleased that this series was launched. I have spent a lifetime wondering what really happened on the 'eastern front' and whether we, in the west, would ever gain any insight into the Soviet point of view on this enormous historical event. Now, I think Black Cross-Red Star will solve that problem for me.

* Jim Haycraft, aviation history researcher:
"I'm very much impressed with this new work and I'm sure many others will be also."

* Sharon Pappas, Paul Gaudette Books:
"Congratulations! I have the book in stock and am very impressed. It is the kind of book that I can sell sight unseen over the phone."

* Review by Dave Williams, WW II Aviation Booklist:
"Black Cross Red Star: The Air War Over the Eastern Front; Vol. 1, 1941 Christer Bergstrom & Andrey Mikhailov, Pacifica CA: Pacifica Military History, 2000, 307 pp (hb)
ISBN: 0 935553 48 7
Authors, Bergstrom and Mikhailov make their North American debut with an exhaustive (and what promises to be a definitive) treatment of the airwar on the Russian front. The sheer breadth of the subject matter is staggering; yet Bergstrom and Mikhailov carry the reader along on a fast paced journey into the very center of the conflict. The text is exceptionally well researched and features invaluable passages translated from unpublished works such as Hannes Trautloft's diary and flight book entries of both Russian and German airmen. The detail provided is impressive and the book presents a carefully scrutinized look at the full scope of the conflict courtesy of balanced reporting from both the Soviet and German perspectives. From close-up in-cockpit tactical accounts to the broader strategic picture including orders of battle, Black Cross Red Star is an absolute must buy for anyone wanting to know more about the air war on the Eastern front. Even better, this book represents only the first entry of what will be a 4 volume set! I was particularly struck by the absolute scale of events in this theatre of war and the unfathomable levels of destruction unleashed by both sides. Of note...the book dispels the veil of propaganda that has tainted most of the West's understanding of the Eastern front and successfully humanizes its combatants. Indispensible contribution to our understanding of the air war on the Eastern front...An absolute must have!"
http://www.jackedin.com/prop/generaleuro.html


Bestselling rating on Amazon.com, September 3, 2000:
"Books Search Results: 376 total matches for 'Aerial operations, German'. The most popular are (Results sorted by: Bestselling):

  1. Black Cross/Red Star : Vol. 1, Operation Barbarossa 1941
  2. I Flew for the Fuhrer by Heinz Knoke

"Books Search Results: 71 total matches for 'Aerial operations, Soviet' The most popular are (Results sorted by: Bestselling):

  1. Black Cross/Red Star : Vol. 1, Operation Barbarossa 1941
  2. The History of Soviet Airborne Forces by David M. Glantz.

"Books Search Results: 1156 total matches for 'Military - Aviation' Results sorted by: Bestselling

10. Black Cross/Red Star : Vol. 1, Operation Barbarossa 1941
http://www.amazon.com

 

Bestselling rating on Amazon.com, April 9, 2001:
"Books Search Results: 370 total matches for 'Aerial operations, German'. The most popular are (Results sorted by: Bestselling):

  1. Black Cross/Red Star : Vol. 1, Operation Barbarossa 1941
  2. Messerschmitt Bf 109 : Luftwaffe Fighter (Living History , Vol 5) by Dan Patterson (Photographer),
    http://www.amazon.com

. . .

Still rated as #1 bestselling in cathegory "Aerial operations German"at Amazon.com on August 10, 2001, though the book at position #2 has shifted.


Back to Main Page